Auto Burglary
Table of contents
Click To travel To Chapters
1. What is Auto Burglary?
2. What are examples of Auto Burglary?
Auto burglary, as defined under California Penal Code 459 PC, occurs when someone unlawfully enters a locked vehicle with the intent to commit theft or a felony. To better understand how this law applies, it helps to examine real-life scenarios where individuals have committed auto burglary. Below are several examples that illustrate what actions can lead to a charge of auto burglary in California.
1. Breaking a Window to Steal Items
One of the most common examples of auto burglary involves smashing a car window to steal items inside. If a person uses a rock, crowbar, or other object to break the window of a locked car and then takes valuables such as a purse, wallet, or electronics, they have committed auto burglary.
Example:
Scenario: John sees a laptop inside a parked, locked car. He uses a rock to break the window, reaches in, and takes the laptop. Even if he’s caught before he can leave with the stolen item, the fact that he entered the locked vehicle with the intent to steal qualifies as auto burglary.
2. Using a Tool to Unlock a Car
Using any tool to unlock a vehicle also qualifies as auto burglary, as long as the car was locked, and the person had the intent to commit theft or another felony.
Example:
Scenario: Lisa sees a locked car with a purse on the passenger seat. She uses a coat hanger to unlock the door, planning to steal the purse. Whether or not she successfully takes the purse, she has already committed auto burglary by entering the locked vehicle with criminal intent.
3. Reaching Through an Open Window to Steal
You don’t need to fully enter a vehicle to be guilty of auto burglary. Simply reaching into a car through a slightly open window can still count as “entering” the vehicle under California law. If this is done with the intent to steal or commit a felony, it qualifies as auto burglary.
Example:
Scenario: On a hot day, Mark notices that a car’s windows are rolled down a few inches to let air in. He sees a phone on the driver’s seat, and he reaches through the window to grab it. Even though he never fully entered the car, Mark is guilty of auto burglary because he used the opening to steal something.
4. Stealing Items from a Locked Trunk
Auto burglary can also apply when someone breaks into the locked trunk of a car to steal valuables. Entering any locked part of the vehicle, including the trunk, can lead to this charge.
Example:
Scenario: Rachel finds a locked car and notices that its trunk has a valuable suitcase inside. She uses a screwdriver to force the trunk open and steals the suitcase. By breaking into the locked trunk with the intent to commit theft, Rachel is guilty of auto burglary.
5. Breaking into a Vehicle to Commit Another Felony
Auto burglary does not always involve theft. If a person breaks into a locked vehicle with the intent to commit any felony, they can be charged with auto burglary. This could include actions like planning to kidnap someone inside the vehicle or to commit another serious crime.
Example:
Scenario: A person breaks into a car with the intent to assault someone who is inside. Even though they are not planning to steal anything, the intent to commit a felony (assault) is enough to constitute auto burglary under California law.
6. Attempting to Steal a Vehicle (Grand Theft Auto)
When someone breaks into a locked car with the intent to steal the vehicle itself, they can be charged with both auto burglary and grand theft auto. In these cases, the person’s intent is to take the car rather than its contents.
Example:
Scenario: James uses a crowbar to break into a car, intending to drive away with the vehicle. Even if he doesn’t succeed in stealing the car, he can still be charged with auto burglary because he unlawfully entered a locked vehicle with the intent to commit a felony (grand theft auto).
7. Entering a Locked RV or Trailer
If someone breaks into a locked RV or trailer with the intent to steal or commit a felony, they can be charged with auto burglary. However, if the RV or trailer is inhabited, the charge may be elevated to first-degree burglary, which carries more severe penalties.
Example:
Scenario: Matt breaks into a locked RV parked at a campsite, planning to steal electronics from inside. Since the RV was locked and his intent was theft, Matt is guilty of auto burglary. If the RV had been inhabited at the time, this could have been charged as first-degree burglary.
3. What are the penalties for Auto Burglary?
Auto burglary is a serious crime in California, with penalties that can vary depending on the circumstances of the offense and the defendant’s criminal history. Under California Penal Code 459 PC, auto burglary is generally considered a form of second-degree burglary, which is a “wobbler” offense—meaning it can be charged as either a misdemeanor or a felony. Let’s explore the penalties for auto burglary in California and the factors that influence how the crime is charged.
Misdemeanor vs. Felony Auto Burglary
The penalties for auto burglary in California largely depend on whether the offense is charged as a misdemeanor or a felony. Several factors influence this decision, including:
The specific circumstances of the crime (such as the method of entry and whether theft was successful).
The defendant’s prior criminal record (whether or not they have previous convictions).
The value of the property stolen, if any.
Penalties for Misdemeanor Auto Burglary
If auto burglary is charged as a misdemeanor, the penalties are less severe but still impactful. A misdemeanor conviction can result in:
Up to one (1) year in county jail.
Fines of up to $1,000.
Probation, which may include conditions such as attending theft prevention programs or performing community service.
While a misdemeanor is a less serious charge, it still carries lasting consequences, including a criminal record that can affect employment, housing, and other aspects of life.
Penalties for Felony Auto Burglary
If auto burglary is charged as a felony, the penalties are much more severe. A felony conviction can result in:
16 months, 2 years, or 3 years in county jail (due to California’s realignment laws, many felonies are served in county jail instead of state prison).
Fines that can go up to $10,000.
Probation, with conditions that may include restitution to the victim, community service, or counseling.
Felony auto burglary convictions can also lead to longer-term consequences such as difficulties in finding employment, housing, or professional licensing due to the felony on your record.
First-Degree vs. Second-Degree Auto Burglary
In almost all cases, auto burglary is considered second-degree burglary, which applies to burglaries that occur in vehicles, commercial properties, or other non-residential settings. However, there is one situation in which auto burglary may be classified as first-degree burglary, which carries more serious penalties:
Breaking into an inhabited vehicle: If the vehicle broken into is a “trailer coach” (such as an RV or motorhome) where someone is living, the crime can be elevated to first-degree burglary.
For first-degree burglary, the penalties include:
2, 4, or 6 years in state prison.
Higher fines and other stricter penalties compared to second-degree burglary.
Factors That Affect Auto Burglary Penalties
There are several factors that influence how auto burglary is charged and sentenced. These include:
The value of the stolen property: If the theft involved property valued at $950 or more, it may lead to additional charges like grand theft, which can increase the severity of the punishment.
Use of a weapon: If a weapon was involved during the burglary, it could result in additional charges and more severe penalties.
Prior convictions: If the defendant has a history of prior convictions, especially for theft-related offenses, they are more likely to face felony charges and harsher sentences.
Inhabited vehicle: As mentioned, breaking into an inhabited vehicle or RV may elevate the charge to first-degree burglary.
Additional Consequences of an Auto Burglary Conviction
Beyond jail time and fines, an auto burglary conviction can have lasting consequences that affect various aspects of your life:
Criminal record: A conviction will stay on your criminal record and may appear in background checks, making it difficult to secure jobs, housing, or professional licenses.
Restitution: In cases where the burglary caused financial harm to the victim (such as damage to the vehicle or stolen property), the court may order restitution, requiring the defendant to pay for the damages.
Probation requirements: If probation is granted, it often comes with strict conditions such as attending court-ordered programs, checking in with a probation officer, and avoiding any further legal trouble.
4. What are legal defenses for Auto Burglary?
Auto burglary, as defined by California Penal Code 459 PC, is a serious crime that can result in harsh penalties, including jail time and fines. However, there are several legal defenses that a skilled criminal defense attorney can use to fight these charges. A successful defense can result in a reduction or dismissal of charges, or even an acquittal at trial. Let’s explore some of the most effective legal defenses against auto burglary charges in California.
1. The Vehicle Was Not Locked
One of the fundamental elements of auto burglary is that the vehicle in question must have been locked at the time of the alleged break-in. If the prosecution cannot prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the vehicle was locked, the defendant cannot be convicted of auto burglary.
Example:
Scenario: Sarah is accused of breaking into a car and stealing a wallet. However, it turns out that the car door was left unlocked. In this case, Sarah’s attorney can argue that the vehicle wasn’t locked, which is a critical requirement for the charge of auto burglary. As a result, Sarah may be acquitted of the charge.
2. Lack of Intent to Commit Theft or a Felony
Auto burglary requires that the defendant had the intent to commit theft or a felony at the time they entered the locked vehicle. If there was no such intent, the charge of auto burglary cannot stand. This defense is especially useful in cases where the person entered the vehicle for a different reason, such as by mistake or without any criminal purpose.
Example:
Scenario: Mike is seen entering a locked car, but he claims he was checking on his friend’s car, thinking it was left unlocked. If Mike’s attorney can prove that he had no intention to steal or commit a felony, the auto burglary charge may be dismissed.
3. Mistaken Identity
In some cases, the defendant may be falsely accused of committing auto burglary due to mistaken identity. This is particularly common when the alleged crime occurs in a busy or poorly lit area where it may be difficult for witnesses to accurately identify the perpetrator.
Example:
Scenario: Josh is arrested for auto burglary after a witness sees someone breaking into a car. However, Josh’s defense attorney presents evidence that he was at work at the time of the incident and could not have committed the crime. By proving mistaken identity, Josh may be cleared of all charges.
4. Insufficient Evidence
For any criminal conviction, the prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. If the evidence against the defendant is weak, incomplete, or circumstantial, the defense can argue that the prosecution has not met its burden of proof. Without strong evidence that the defendant committed the crime, the case may be dismissed or the defendant acquitted.
Example:
Scenario: A vehicle is broken into, but there is no surveillance footage, no fingerprints, and no clear evidence linking the defendant to the crime. The defense attorney argues that the prosecution has insufficient evidence to prove the defendant committed auto burglary, leading to a possible dismissal of the charges.
5. Claim of Right
The claim of right defense applies when the defendant had a reasonable belief that they had the legal right to enter the vehicle or take the property in question. This defense can be used if the defendant mistakenly believed the car or its contents belonged to them or if they had permission to enter the vehicle.
Example:
Scenario: Maria is accused of breaking into a locked car and taking a bag from the backseat. However, Maria’s defense is that she believed the car belonged to her friend and she was retrieving her own bag. If she can prove that she had a genuine belief in her right to enter the vehicle, she may be acquitted of the charge.
6. No Forced Entry
For auto burglary charges to stick, there must be evidence that the defendant somehow altered or tampered with the vehicle to gain entry (e.g., breaking a window or picking a lock). If there was no forced entry, or if the defendant entered the vehicle with the owner’s permission, the charge of auto burglary may not apply.
Example:
Scenario: A person is accused of auto burglary after being found inside a car. However, the car’s owner testifies that they gave the individual permission to enter the car. Since no forced entry occurred, and permission was granted, the auto burglary charge is likely to be dismissed.
7. Duress or Coercion
In some cases, an individual may have been forced or threatened into committing auto burglary by another person. The duress defense applies when the defendant committed the crime because they were under an immediate threat of harm or violence.
Example:
Scenario: Jack is forced at gunpoint to break into a car and steal its contents. Because he was acting under duress and feared for his life, Jack’s attorney may use this defense to argue that he should not be held criminally liable for the burglary.
8. False Accusation
Sometimes, individuals are falsely accused of auto burglary due to personal vendettas, misunderstandings, or dishonest testimony. A defense attorney can investigate the circumstances surrounding the accusation and present evidence to show that the charges were fabricated or exaggerated.
Example:
Scenario: Kevin is accused of breaking into his ex-girlfriend’s car. However, his attorney uncovers text messages showing that she was upset with him and may have falsely accused him to get revenge. With this evidence, the attorney can argue that the accusation is baseless and the charges should be dropped.
our clients say it best
Client Testimonials
5. What are related offenses to Auto Burglary?
Protecting Your Rights, Defending Your Future
Get in touch with our lawyers today to schedule a consultation and learn how we can help you. We are here to answer your questions and provide you with the support you need during this difficult time.
Client Satisfaction Is Priority
You Are More Than What They Say
We Always Go The Extra Mile