Bribery
Table of contents
Click To travel To Chapters
1. What is Bribery?
2. What are examples of Bribery?
Bribery is a serious crime in California, involving the offer, acceptance, or solicitation of something valuable in exchange for influencing the actions of a public official, business decision-maker, or someone in a position of authority. Bribery can occur in both the public and private sectors, and it doesn’t always involve large sums of money. It can range from government corruption to corporate fraud, and it is often done with the intent of gaining an unfair advantage or bypassing legal processes.
Below are some common examples of bribery to help illustrate how the crime can occur under different circumstances.
1. Bribery Involving Public Officials
One of the most common forms of bribery involves public officials, where a person offers money, gifts, or other benefits to a government employee or elected official to influence their decision-making or actions.
Example 1: Bribing a City Inspector
Scenario: A business owner, Laura, wants to open a new restaurant but knows that her building does not meet the city’s health and safety regulations. To avoid the cost and time of bringing the building up to code, she offers the city health inspector $10,000 in cash to approve her permit regardless of the violations. This is a clear example of bribery because Laura is offering money to unlawfully influence the inspector’s decision.
Example 2: Political Bribery
Scenario: An influential lobbyist offers a state senator an all-expenses-paid vacation to Hawaii in exchange for the senator’s vote on a bill that will benefit the lobbyist’s corporate clients. This is bribery because the lobbyist is offering something of value to influence the senator’s official actions in the legislature.
2. Judicial Bribery
Judicial bribery occurs when someone attempts to bribe a judge, court official, or jury member in order to influence the outcome of a legal case.
Example: Bribing a Judge
Scenario: John is facing a serious criminal charge and knows that if convicted, he could spend years in prison. His attorney suggests that he offer the judge $50,000 to dismiss the case or impose a lighter sentence. Offering a judge money to sway the outcome of a court case is judicial bribery and is punishable by severe legal consequences, including imprisonment.
3. Bribery of Law Enforcement
Bribing law enforcement officials, such as police officers, in exchange for leniency or to avoid legal consequences is a common form of bribery. This typically involves offering money or other benefits to avoid arrest, citations, or penalties.
Example: Bribing a Police Officer
Scenario: Paul is pulled over for driving under the influence of alcohol. When the officer approaches, Paul offers him $1,000 in cash if he lets him go without a ticket or arrest. This is bribery, as Paul is offering money in exchange for the officer to ignore his legal duty to enforce the law.
4. Commercial Bribery
In the private sector, bribery often takes the form of commercial bribery, where one party offers something of value to a business decision-maker in exchange for favorable treatment in business dealings, contracts, or hiring.
Example 1: Bribery for a Business Contract
Scenario: A construction company is bidding for a large government contract. To ensure that their bid is selected, the company’s CEO offers the project manager overseeing the selection process $100,000 in exchange for awarding them the contract. This is an example of commercial bribery, where a business is trying to gain an unfair advantage by offering money to influence a decision.
Example 2: Bribery in Hiring
Scenario: Susan wants to secure a high-level executive job at a major corporation. To improve her chances of being hired, she offers the company’s hiring manager expensive gifts and an additional payment under the table if they choose her for the role. This constitutes bribery because she is using money and gifts to influence the hiring decision.
5. Bribery in Sports and Entertainment
Bribery can also occur in sports and entertainment, where individuals or companies try to influence the outcome of events or decisions related to awards, endorsements, or competition results.
Example: Bribery in Sports
Scenario: A professional athlete is offered a large sum of money by a betting syndicate to purposely underperform in an upcoming game, thus influencing the outcome of the match in favor of the syndicate’s bet. This is considered sports bribery, where the athlete is being paid to manipulate the results of a competitive event.
6. Bribery in Academic Settings
Bribery can also take place in educational institutions, often involving students or parents offering money or favors to teachers, administrators, or admissions officers to gain admission, better grades, or other advantages.
Example: College Admissions Scandal
Scenario: A wealthy parent offers a university admissions officer $50,000 in exchange for ensuring that their child is admitted to a prestigious college, despite not meeting the academic qualifications. This is bribery because the parent is using money to unlawfully influence the admissions process.
7. Bribery of Foreign Officials
Bribing foreign officials is a specific crime under both California law and federal laws, such as the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA). This type of bribery occurs when individuals or companies offer bribes to officials in foreign governments in exchange for business advantages, such as contracts, permits, or regulatory approvals.
Example: Bribing a Foreign Government Official
Scenario: A U.S.-based multinational corporation offers a $1 million bribe to a foreign government official to secure exclusive mining rights in the country. This is a violation of both California bribery laws and federal anti-corruption laws.
8. Bribery in Elections
Bribery in the context of elections occurs when someone offers money or gifts to voters or election officials in exchange for votes or favorable treatment in the election process.
Example: Vote Buying
Scenario: A candidate for local office offers cash payments to voters in exchange for casting their ballots in his favor. This is illegal and is considered electoral bribery, as the candidate is attempting to influence the outcome of the election through unlawful means.
3. What are the penalties for Bribery?
Bribery is a serious crime in California that involves offering, accepting, or soliciting something of value to influence the actions of a public official or someone in a position of power. Whether it takes place in government, business, or legal proceedings, bribery undermines fairness and trust in public and private systems. Because of this, the penalties for bribery in California are severe and can result in significant prison time, fines, and other long-term consequences. Below, we break down the penalties for bribery under California law, based on the specific type of bribery offense.
1. Bribery of Public Officials (Penal Code 67-68 PC)
One of the most serious forms of bribery involves public officials, such as government employees, elected officials, or law enforcement officers. Offering or accepting a bribe to influence a public official’s duties is a felony under California law.
Penalties for Public Official Bribery:
Imprisonment: A conviction for bribing or being bribed as a public official can result in 2 to 4 years in state prison.
Fines: A fine of up to $10,000 may be imposed, or a fine equal to three times the value of the bribe, whichever is greater. For larger bribes, this can result in very substantial financial penalties.
Felony Probation: In some cases, a judge may sentence the defendant to felony probation instead of prison time. This may involve conditions like community service, paying restitution, and regular check-ins with a probation officer.
Example:
Scenario: A business owner offers a city official $20,000 in exchange for approving a zoning change that would benefit their business. If convicted, the business owner faces up to 4 years in prison and a fine of at least $60,000 (three times the amount of the bribe).
2. Judicial Bribery (Penal Code 92-93 PC)
Bribing a judge, juror, or other court official to influence the outcome of a legal case is also a felony in California. This form of bribery carries even more serious consequences because it directly affects the integrity of the judicial system.
Penalties for Judicial Bribery:
Imprisonment: A conviction can result in 2 to 4 years in state prison.
Fines: A fine of up to $10,000 or three times the value of the bribe, whichever is greater.
Disqualification: A judge, juror, or court official convicted of bribery will be permanently disqualified from holding public office.
Example:
Scenario: A defendant facing criminal charges offers a judge $50,000 to dismiss the case. If convicted, the defendant could face up to 4 years in prison and a fine of $150,000 (three times the value of the bribe).
3. Bribery of Law Enforcement (Penal Code 67 PC)
Offering a bribe to law enforcement, such as a police officer, to avoid arrest or receive favorable treatment is also a felony under California law. This type of bribery carries the same penalties as bribery of public officials.
Penalties for Bribery of Law Enforcement:
Imprisonment: A conviction can result in 2 to 4 years in state prison.
Fines: Up to $10,000 or three times the value of the bribe, whichever is greater.
Felony Probation: In some cases, felony probation may be granted as an alternative to prison.
Example:
Scenario: A driver pulled over for a DUI offers the police officer $5,000 to avoid arrest. If convicted, the driver could face up to 4 years in state prison and a fine of at least $15,000 (three times the value of the bribe).
4. Commercial Bribery (Penal Code 641.3 PC)
Commercial bribery occurs in the private sector and involves offering or accepting a bribe to influence business decisions, such as awarding contracts, securing favorable terms, or giving preferential treatment in hiring. The penalties for commercial bribery depend on the value of the bribe.
Penalties for Commercial Bribery:
If the bribe is $1,000 or less:
Misdemeanor: Up to 1 year in county jail and fines up to $1,000.
If the bribe is more than $1,000:
Felony: 16 months, 2 years, or 3 years in state prison.
Fines: Up to $10,000 or three times the value of the bribe, whichever is greater.
Example:
Scenario: A contractor offers a company’s purchasing manager $2,000 to select their bid for a major project. The purchasing manager accepts the bribe. Both the contractor and the manager could be charged with commercial bribery, facing up to 3 years in prison and fines up to $6,000 (three times the amount of the bribe).
5. Aggravating Factors
Several factors can make bribery charges more severe and result in harsher penalties:
Bribes involving large sums of money: The higher the value of the bribe, the more severe the penalties, especially when fines are calculated based on three times the value of the bribe.
Impact on public trust: Bribery that affects public services, government agencies, or law enforcement tends to carry heavier penalties due to the impact on public trust and the integrity of public institutions.
Multiple offenses: Defendants with prior convictions or multiple bribery-related charges may face longer sentences and larger fines.
6. Consequences Beyond Criminal Penalties
In addition to prison time and fines, a bribery conviction can have serious long-term consequences, including:
Loss of Employment: A public official or employee convicted of bribery will likely lose their job and may be permanently barred from holding public office.
Professional Disqualification: Certain professions, such as lawyers, accountants, and government contractors, may be disqualified from practicing if convicted of bribery.
Criminal Record: A felony conviction for bribery can result in a permanent criminal record, affecting future job prospects, housing opportunities, and the ability to obtain professional licenses.
Civil Lawsuits: The victim of bribery, such as a defrauded business or government entity, may file a civil lawsuit to recover damages from the defendant.
7. Expungement of a Bribery Conviction
A bribery conviction can sometimes be expunged from a person’s criminal record, depending on the circumstances. Expungement is available if:
The conviction was for a misdemeanor or a felony where probation was successfully completed.
The defendant did not serve time in state prison. (If state prison time was served, expungement is not available.)
If a conviction is expunged, it can improve future job prospects and restore certain civil rights, though it may not completely erase all consequences of the conviction.
4. What are legal defenses for Bribery?
Bribery is a serious offense in California that involves offering, giving, receiving, or soliciting something of value to unlawfully influence the actions of a public official, business decision-maker, or someone in a position of power. A conviction can result in severe penalties, including imprisonment, hefty fines, and long-lasting damage to your reputation. However, like many criminal charges, there are several legal defenses that may be available to fight bribery accusations.
In this article, we explore some of the most common and effective defenses that can be used in bribery cases under California law.
1. Lack of Corrupt Intent
One of the key elements of a bribery charge is corrupt intent. For a defendant to be convicted of bribery, the prosecution must prove that the person offering or accepting the bribe did so with the corrupt intent to unlawfully influence the decision-making process. If the defendant did not have this corrupt intent, they may not be guilty of bribery.
How This Defense Works:
The defense argues that the exchange was made for legitimate purposes and not to influence an official or business decision.
The prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant had a corrupt motive. Without clear evidence of intent to influence, the charges may be dismissed or reduced.
Example:
Scenario: Mark gives a city official tickets to a sports game as a friendly gesture. The prosecution accuses Mark of bribing the official to obtain a business permit. Mark’s defense attorney argues that there was no corrupt intent behind the gift and that it was not given to influence the official’s decision.
2. Entrapment
Entrapment is a common defense in bribery cases, especially when law enforcement uses undercover operations or sting operations to catch suspects in the act of bribing someone. Entrapment occurs when law enforcement induces a person to commit a crime they would not have otherwise committed. If the defendant can show that they were coerced or pressured into committing bribery by police, they may have a valid defense.
How This Defense Works:
The defense must prove that the idea to commit bribery originated with law enforcement and that the defendant was persuaded or pressured into committing the crime.
Entrapment is only a defense if the defendant can demonstrate that they would not have committed the crime without the encouragement of law enforcement.
Example:
Scenario: An undercover officer approaches Jane, pretending to be a government official, and repeatedly pressures her to offer a bribe in exchange for a contract. Jane initially refuses but eventually agrees after the officer insists. In this case, Jane’s attorney can argue that she was entrapped and would not have committed bribery without the officer’s coercion.
3. False Accusation
Bribery accusations can arise from personal conflicts, misunderstandings, or ulterior motives. A person may be falsely accused of bribery by someone looking to gain revenge, shift blame, or avoid legal consequences themselves. If the defense can show that the accusation is false or based on unreliable evidence, the charges may be dismissed.
How This Defense Works:
The defense gathers evidence to demonstrate that the bribery accusation is false, such as phone records, emails, or witness testimony.
This defense often applies when the defendant has been accused by someone with a personal vendetta or when there is insufficient evidence to support the accusation.
Example:
Scenario: Tim is a city contractor accused of bribing a city inspector to approve his work. However, it turns out that a rival contractor made the accusation out of jealousy. Tim’s defense attorney uncovers evidence of the rival’s motive, leading to the dismissal of the bribery charges.
4. No Quid Pro Quo
In bribery cases, the prosecution must often prove that there was a clear exchange (known as quid pro quo)—something of value given in return for a specific favor or action. If there was no agreement or understanding that the bribe was offered in exchange for a specific decision or action, the bribery charges may not hold up in court.
How This Defense Works:
The defense argues that the item of value was not given in exchange for any specific favor, action, or outcome, and that there was no “quid pro quo” arrangement.
Without evidence of a clear agreement to exchange something of value for an official act, bribery may be difficult to prove.
Example:
Scenario: Sarah gives a government official a gift card after receiving a favorable decision in her favor. The prosecution accuses her of bribing the official, but her attorney argues that there was no prior agreement or promise in exchange for the decision. Without clear evidence of a quid pro quo, the bribery charges may be dropped.
5. Coercion or Duress
In some cases, a person may commit bribery under coercion or duress, meaning they were forced to offer or accept a bribe due to threats of harm or pressure. If the defendant can demonstrate that they only committed the act because of threats or intimidation, they may have a valid defense.
How This Defense Works:
The defense must show that the defendant acted under the belief that they or someone else would face immediate harm if they did not participate in the bribery.
This defense is applicable if the defendant was not acting voluntarily and was under extreme pressure to commit the crime.
Example:
Scenario: Carlos is threatened by a powerful business executive who demands that he offer a bribe to a public official or face severe financial consequences. If Carlos can show that he was coerced into committing bribery due to these threats, his defense attorney can argue that he acted under duress.
6. Lack of Evidence
For the prosecution to secure a conviction for bribery, they must provide substantial evidence to prove that the defendant committed the crime. If there is insufficient evidence to establish that a bribe was offered or accepted, the defense can argue that the prosecution has failed to meet its burden of proof.
How This Defense Works:
The defense attorney challenges the credibility or reliability of the evidence presented by the prosecution, such as witness testimony, documentation, or recordings.
If the prosecution’s evidence is weak, incomplete, or lacks critical details, the bribery charges may be dismissed.
Example:
Scenario: Tom is accused of bribing a government official, but the only evidence is a vague conversation between him and the official that does not clearly indicate bribery. Tom’s defense attorney challenges the evidence, arguing that there is no concrete proof of a bribe. As a result, the case is dismissed due to lack of evidence.
our clients say it best
Client Testimonials
5. What are related offenses to Bribery?
Protecting Your Rights, Defending Your Future
Get in touch with our lawyers today to schedule a consultation and learn how we can help you. We are here to answer your questions and provide you with the support you need during this difficult time.
Client Satisfaction Is Priority
You Are More Than What They Say
We Always Go The Extra Mile