Deferred Entry of Judgment

Table of contents

Click To travel To Chapters

1. What is Deferred Entry of Judgment?

Deferred Entry of Judgment (DEJ) is a legal process that allows defendants in California to avoid a criminal conviction on their record under certain conditions. The DEJ program provides an opportunity for individuals facing criminal charges to enter a plea of guilty or no contest, but with the stipulation that the judge does not immediately enter a judgment or conviction. Instead, the defendant is placed on probation and given the chance to fulfill specific requirements, such as completing community service, attending counseling or treatment programs, or undergoing rehabilitation.

If the defendant successfully completes the terms of their probation, the court will dismiss the case, and no conviction will appear on their criminal record. However, if the defendant fails to meet the conditions of probation, the court will enter a judgment and impose a sentence based on the original plea.

The Deferred Entry of Judgment program is commonly used for non-violent offenses, including drug possession, minor theft, and certain misdemeanors. It serves as an alternative to traditional sentencing and provides individuals with the chance to resolve their case without a permanent criminal record.

Key Differences Between DEJ and Pretrial Diversion

While Deferred Entry of Judgment (DEJ) and Pretrial Diversion programs share some similarities, they are not the same. The key differences between the two are:

Plea Requirement: DEJ requires the defendant to enter a plea of guilty or no contest before beginning probation. Pretrial Diversion, on the other hand, typically does not require any plea until the diversion program is completed or violated.
Consequences of Failing Probation: If a defendant fails probation under DEJ, the court will enter a conviction and impose a sentence based on the original plea. With Pretrial Diversion, the case can proceed as though the defendant never participated in the program, leaving the option for a trial or alternative sentencing.
Eligibility Criteria: DEJ is typically available for individuals charged with misdemeanors or non-violent felonies. Pretrial Diversion can also apply to individuals with mental health conditions or certain drug-related offenses.

Eligibility for Deferred Entry of Judgment

To be eligible for DEJ, the following conditions generally need to be met:

The offense must be a non-violent misdemeanor or certain non-violent felonies.
The defendant must have no prior convictions for offenses that would disqualify them from DEJ.
The defendant must agree to complete the terms of probation, including community service, rehabilitation programs, or other court-ordered conditions.

If these requirements are met and the defendant successfully completes the terms of probation, the court will dismiss the case, and the defendant will avoid a criminal conviction.

Advantages of Deferred Entry of Judgment

The most significant benefit of Deferred Entry of Judgment is the opportunity to avoid a permanent criminal conviction. By successfully completing the probation period, the defendant can have the case dismissed, allowing them to move forward without the stigma of a conviction on their record. This can improve opportunities for employment, housing, and other aspects of life that can be affected by a criminal history.

Additionally, DEJ can provide individuals with the chance to address underlying issues, such as drug or alcohol abuse, anger management, or other behavioral concerns, through mandated treatment programs, contributing to personal rehabilitation.

Limitations and Considerations

While DEJ offers valuable benefits, there are some important considerations to keep in mind:

Failure to Complete Probation: If the defendant fails to comply with probation terms, the case will be reopened, and the defendant will be sentenced based on the original charges.
Federal Record: Though the case may be dismissed under state law, certain federal background checks may still reveal the plea, particularly in matters involving national security or other federal-related jobs.

Deferred Entry of Judgment is a powerful tool for individuals who qualify and are seeking a second chance at avoiding a criminal conviction. If you are facing charges that may be eligible for DEJ, it’s important to understand both the benefits and the potential risks involved. Speaking with an experienced criminal defense attorney can help you determine if DEJ is the right choice for your case and ensure you meet all necessary requirements for program participation.

2. What are Examples of Deferred Entry of Judgment?

Deferred Entry of Judgment (DEJ) is a legal program in California that allows defendants to avoid a criminal conviction on their record if they meet specific probation requirements. This opportunity is typically offered to individuals charged with non-violent offenses, and the successful completion of DEJ can result in a case dismissal.

But what kinds of cases typically qualify for DEJ? Below are examples of the types of offenses where Deferred Entry of Judgment may be applicable.

1. Drug Possession Offenses

One of the most common examples of Deferred Entry of Judgment is for individuals charged with drug possession. Under California law, possession of controlled substances such as marijuana, cocaine, methamphetamine, or heroin can be eligible for DEJ, especially if the defendant has no significant criminal history and is facing a first-time offense.

Example: A person arrested for possession of a small amount of cocaine could be offered DEJ as an alternative to a conviction, provided they meet probation requirements, which may include drug treatment programs, random drug testing, or community service. If the defendant successfully completes the terms of probation, the charge will be dismissed, and no criminal conviction will appear on their record.

2. Minor Theft or Shoplifting Charges

Another example where DEJ is frequently applied is for minor theft offenses, such as shoplifting or petty theft. For individuals accused of stealing low-value items, DEJ can provide a path to dismissal without the long-term consequences of a conviction.

Example: A person caught stealing items worth less than $950 in a store may qualify for DEJ if it’s their first offense. As part of the DEJ program, they may be required to attend theft prevention classes, perform community service, and avoid further legal trouble. If the terms are met, the charge is dismissed after successful completion of probation.

3. Driving Under the Influence (DUI)

For individuals charged with a first-time DUI offense, DEJ can be an option in some cases. While DUI charges are often more serious, a defendant with no prior convictions and a clean driving record may be eligible for DEJ if they agree to complete specific terms, such as alcohol education classes or probation.

Example: A first-time DUI offender who pleads guilty or no contest may be placed in DEJ and required to attend DUI education programs, complete alcohol or drug counseling, and submit to random alcohol tests. Upon successful completion, the DUI charge can be dismissed, and the individual avoids a permanent criminal conviction.

4. Misdemeanor Assault or Battery (Non-Violent)

While violent crimes are typically not eligible for DEJ, certain non-violent misdemeanor assault or battery offenses may be considered for the program. This is especially true in cases where the defendant has no prior criminal history and the crime did not cause significant harm.

Example: A person arrested for a minor altercation in a public space could qualify for DEJ if they have no previous violent crime convictions. The court may order anger management counseling, community service, and probation as part of the DEJ terms. Upon successful completion, the assault or battery charge could be dismissed.

5. Trespassing

Trespassing offenses, particularly those that involve entering property without malicious intent, may also qualify for DEJ. This program can be helpful for individuals who find themselves charged with trespassing due to a misunderstanding or minor infraction.

Example: A person who accidentally trespasses on private property, such as entering a gated area by mistake, might be offered DEJ if they have no prior criminal record. They may be required to complete community service or a probation period, and if successful, the charge will be dismissed.

6. Vandalism (Minor Damage)

Vandalism offenses, where there is minor property damage, may qualify for DEJ, especially when the damage is not severe or malicious. DEJ can help individuals avoid the long-term consequences of a criminal conviction for what may have been a youthful indiscretion or an isolated incident.

Example: A teenager who spray-paints a public wall or damages property may qualify for DEJ. As part of the program, they may be required to pay restitution, complete community service, and attend counseling. If they successfully fulfill these terms, the charge is dismissed, and no conviction is recorded.

7. Public Intoxication

In some cases, individuals arrested for public intoxication may be eligible for DEJ. This is often seen in cases where the intoxication was non-threatening and did not lead to violent or destructive behavior. DEJ can provide an alternative to a conviction, allowing the individual to avoid the long-term effects of a criminal record.

Example: A person arrested for public intoxication might be eligible for DEJ if it’s their first offense and they did not cause harm to themselves or others. The DEJ program may require the defendant to complete alcohol education or community service. If the program is completed successfully, the case is dismissed, and no criminal conviction is entered.

8. Possession of Drug Paraphernalia

Individuals charged with possessing drug paraphernalia, such as pipes or needles, often face the possibility of DEJ. While the possession of such items is illegal, DEJ can offer a second chance to those who may not have a history of substance abuse or criminal behavior.

Example: A person arrested for possessing a marijuana pipe or other drug paraphernalia could qualify for DEJ if they have no prior offenses. They may be required to complete drug treatment programs, probation, or community service. After completing the terms, the charge could be dismissed.

3. What are the Penalties for Deferred Entry of Judgment?

Deferred Entry of Judgment (DEJ) is a legal option in California that allows defendants facing certain charges to avoid a criminal conviction on their record, provided they successfully complete the terms of probation. While DEJ offers many benefits, such as avoiding a permanent criminal record and receiving the opportunity for rehabilitation, it is important to understand the penalties and consequences associated with this process.

The DEJ program requires the defendant to plead guilty or no contest to a charge, but instead of a conviction being entered immediately, the defendant is given the chance to complete probation and meet specific requirements. If they successfully meet these requirements, the case may be dismissed, and no conviction will appear on their record. However, failure to comply with the terms of the DEJ program can result in serious penalties. Here’s an overview of the penalties for Deferred Entry of Judgment.

1. Failure to Complete Probation – Case Reinstatement

The most significant penalty for a defendant in a DEJ program is the possibility of having the case reinstated if they fail to comply with the terms of probation. If the defendant does not meet the required conditions, the judge will enter a conviction, and the case will proceed as if no DEJ program was ever offered. This means that the defendant will face sentencing based on the original charge, and they could face criminal penalties associated with that charge.

Example:
If a defendant is placed on DEJ for a drug possession charge and fails to attend required counseling sessions or violates probation by committing a new offense, the judge will reinstate the original charge. The defendant will then be sentenced according to the penalties for drug possession, which could include fines, jail time, or other legal consequences.

2. Criminal Conviction and Sentencing

If a defendant violates probation or fails to meet the DEJ program’s requirements, the court will enter a conviction. This conviction will be based on the original charges and could result in criminal penalties, such as:

Jail or Prison Time: The defendant may face the possibility of incarceration based on the offense they were initially charged with.
Fines: Additional fines may be imposed based on the severity of the original charge.
Probation Revocation: If the defendant fails probation, they may be placed under more stringent probation terms or even face formal probation after being convicted.
Community Service: If the defendant fails the DEJ program, they may be required to complete additional community service or other rehabilitative requirements as part of their sentence.

These penalties can be severe, especially if the original charge was a felony or involved significant harm or threat to others.

3. Impact on Criminal Record

One of the primary benefits of the DEJ program is the potential to avoid a criminal conviction on your record if you successfully complete probation. However, failure to comply with the DEJ requirements means that the charge will become a permanent part of your criminal record. This can have long-lasting consequences, including difficulty finding employment, securing housing, or applying for professional licenses.

For some jobs, such as those in law enforcement, security, or other fields involving public safety, having a criminal conviction on your record can significantly limit your career prospects. Federal background checks, particularly for national security positions, may also reveal that the defendant entered a plea, even if the case was dismissed in state court.

4. Possible Impact on Future Criminal Cases

Failing to successfully complete a DEJ program and having the original charge reinstated may also impact future criminal cases. A conviction from a previous DEJ can make it more difficult for a defendant to receive a favorable outcome in future legal matters. Judges may view the failure to comply with probation as an indication of the defendant’s lack of responsibility, which could influence the outcome of any subsequent cases.

Example:
If a person who failed a DEJ program for drug possession later faces charges for a different crime, the prosecutor may use the previous failure as evidence of poor behavior or a history of non-compliance, making the defendant more likely to face harsher penalties.

5. Ineligibility for Future DEJ or Diversion Programs

Another penalty that can arise from failing to comply with DEJ is the loss of eligibility for future diversion programs. If a defendant fails probation under DEJ, they may not be able to qualify for other diversionary programs, such as Pretrial Diversion or Mental Health Diversion, in the future. These programs are designed to offer defendants a second chance at avoiding a conviction, and a failed DEJ may close that door for good.

6. Additional Charges for Violating Probation

If a defendant violates probation by committing another crime during the DEJ period, they may face new criminal charges. For example, if a defendant is on DEJ for a drug possession charge and is caught in possession of drugs again, they could face additional charges related to that offense. This could compound the legal issues and penalties the defendant is already facing, leading to even more serious consequences.

4. What are Legal Defenses for Deferred Entry of Judgment?

Deferred Entry of Judgment (DEJ) provides a valuable opportunity for individuals facing criminal charges in California to avoid a permanent conviction on their record, provided they successfully complete probation and meet certain conditions. However, there are circumstances where a defendant may need to present a legal defense to avoid the negative consequences of a DEJ program or the penalties that arise from failing to complete it.

Understanding the legal defenses available in a DEJ case is crucial for defendants who may face challenges in meeting the program’s requirements or who wish to argue against their eligibility for DEJ. In this article, we’ll explore some common legal defenses and strategies that may be used to defend against Deferred Entry of Judgment.

1. Lack of Probable Cause for Arrest

One of the most fundamental defenses in any criminal case, including those eligible for DEJ, is the argument that the arrest was made without probable cause. If law enforcement officers did not have sufficient grounds to believe that a crime had occurred, this could be used as a defense.

Example:
If you were arrested for a drug-related offense but there was no probable cause for law enforcement to suspect you of carrying illegal substances, your attorney could argue that the arrest was unlawful. This could result in the dismissal of the charges and prevent you from being placed in the DEJ program altogether.

2. Improper Search and Seizure

A defense based on the Fourth Amendment, which protects individuals from unreasonable searches and seizures, can be used if evidence was obtained illegally. If law enforcement conducted a search without a warrant or probable cause, any evidence obtained during that search may be deemed inadmissible in court.

Example:
If you were arrested for possession of drugs but the drugs were found during an unlawful search (e.g., officers searched your car without your consent or a warrant), your attorney may argue that the search violated your rights. If successful, this could result in the suppression of evidence and potentially the dismissal of your case, preventing the need for DEJ.

3. Mistaken Identity

Mistaken identity is another defense that can be used in DEJ cases. If the defendant was wrongly identified as the person who committed the crime, this can serve as a legal defense against the charge. In such cases, the defendant may argue that they were not the individual involved in the offense and, therefore, are not eligible for DEJ.

Example:
If someone was accused of stealing items from a store but was not the person caught on camera or identified by witnesses, they may argue that they were mistakenly identified. Successfully proving this defense could lead to the dismissal of charges and the avoidance of the DEJ program.

4. No Intent to Commit the Offense

Some offenses require a specific intent to commit the crime. If the defendant can prove that they did not have the necessary intent to commit the offense, this could serve as a defense. For example, in cases involving theft or drug possession, showing that the defendant did not intend to steal or possess drugs could undermine the charge and make them ineligible for DEJ.

Example:
A person charged with theft may argue that they accidentally took an item without realizing it, and there was no criminal intent to steal. If this defense is successful, the case may be dismissed, and DEJ may not be necessary.

5. Alibi Defense

An alibi defense is one of the strongest defenses in any criminal case. If the defendant can provide evidence that they were somewhere else when the crime occurred, this could lead to a dismissal of the charges and prevent the need for DEJ. An alibi can be supported by witness testimony, surveillance footage, or other physical evidence.

Example:
If someone is charged with vandalism but can provide an alibi—such as evidence that they were at work or another location at the time of the alleged crime—the court may dismiss the case, and DEJ may not be necessary.

6. Lack of Knowledge or Control

In cases such as drug possession or theft, a defendant may argue that they did not have knowledge of the contraband or stolen property in their possession or that they had no control over it. For example, if drugs were found in a vehicle the defendant was riding in but the defendant did not know the drugs were present, they may argue that they should not be held responsible.

Example:
A defendant accused of possessing illegal substances in their vehicle may argue that they were unaware of the drugs and had no control over them. If successful, this could result in a dismissal of charges and prevent the need for DEJ.

7. Involuntary Confession

If the defendant was coerced or pressured into confessing to the crime, this could serve as a defense. Under California law, confessions obtained through illegal means, such as intimidation or threats, are not admissible in court. If a confession is proven to have been involuntary, it may be excluded from evidence, potentially leading to the dismissal of the case.

Example:
If a defendant confessed to a crime after being threatened or coerced by law enforcement officers, the defense attorney could argue that the confession was involuntary. If the court agrees, this could result in the exclusion of the confession and the dismissal of the case.

8. Inability to Complete DEJ Requirements

If a defendant is unable to meet the requirements of the DEJ program, such as completing mandatory drug counseling, attending probation meetings, or fulfilling community service hours, their attorney may argue that the defendant’s circumstances prevent them from completing the program. This could include cases of mental health issues, severe addiction, or other personal circumstances that make it impossible to comply with probation conditions.

Example:
If a defendant is required to attend a substance abuse treatment program but suffers from a severe medical or mental health issue that prevents participation, their attorney may argue that they should be excused from the program. In some cases, the court may offer an alternative solution or dismiss the case.

9. Duress or Coercion

If the defendant committed the alleged crime under duress or coercion, meaning they were forced to commit the crime due to threats or fear of harm, they may raise this defense. Duress is a valid defense in California, and it could prevent a conviction, including in cases that may otherwise qualify for DEJ.

Example:
A defendant who was forced to commit a crime under threat of harm (such as being coerced into committing theft or transporting illegal substances) could argue that they were under duress at the time. This defense could lead to a dismissal of charges and prevent the need for DEJ.

our clients say it best

Client Testimonials

5. What are Related Offenses to Deferred Entry of Judgment?

Deferred Entry of Judgment (DEJ) provides an important opportunity for individuals facing certain criminal charges in California to avoid a permanent conviction on their record. However, DEJ is not available for all types of crimes. Instead, it is typically used for non-violent offenses, particularly those where the defendant has no significant prior criminal history. It is important for defendants to understand which offenses are eligible for DEJ and which related offenses may influence their eligibility for this program.

In this article, we will explore the types of related offenses that may be considered when seeking DEJ, including those that are eligible and those that are typically excluded from the program.

1. Non-Violent Misdemeanors

The primary category of offenses eligible for DEJ is non-violent misdemeanors. These offenses are generally considered to be minor crimes that do not pose a serious threat to public safety. Non-violent misdemeanors are the most common types of charges for which DEJ is granted.