Penal Code § 372 & § 373a PC - Public Nuisance
Table of contents
Click To travel To Chapters
1. What is Penal Code § 372 & § 373a PC?
Penal Code § 372 & § 373a PC Law Reads As Followed:
2. What Are Examples of Penal Code § 372 & § 373a PC?
Penal Code §§ 372 and 373a PC address public nuisance violations in California, focusing on actions or conditions that harm the health, safety, or well-being of a community. To understand these laws better, here are examples of conduct that could qualify as public nuisances under these statutes.
Examples of Violations Under Penal Code § 372 PC
Penal Code § 372 PC makes it a crime to create or maintain a public nuisance. Below are some common scenarios:
1. Operating a Polluting Business
A manufacturing plant releases harmful chemicals into a nearby waterway, affecting the health of local residents.
A factory emits noxious fumes into a residential neighborhood, making it difficult for people to enjoy their homes or live healthily.
2. Unsafe Property Conditions
An abandoned property becomes a hotspot for illegal activities, such as drug use or vandalism.
A homeowner fails to secure a deteriorating building, which poses a danger to neighbors and passersby.
3. Illegal Animal Breeding or Hoarding
A person breeds animals in unsanitary conditions, leading to bad odors and public health concerns in the area.
A resident hoards dozens of animals in their home, creating unsafe living conditions and health risks for the community.
4. Noise Disturbances
A nightclub consistently plays excessively loud music late into the night, disturbing nearby residents.
Construction companies fail to adhere to noise ordinances, creating excessive noise pollution during prohibited hours.
5. Obstructing Public Areas
A business places permanent, unauthorized barriers on a public sidewalk, forcing pedestrians to walk in the street.
A vendor sets up shop in a public park and blocks pathways, making it difficult for the community to enjoy the space.
Examples of Violations Under Penal Code § 373a PC
Penal Code § 373a PC specifically targets public nuisances that are allowed to exist on private property after the property owner receives proper notice to correct the problem. Examples include:
1. Persistent Noise Complaints
A landlord receives notice about tenants throwing frequent parties that disrupt the neighborhood, but the landlord fails to take action.
2. Dangerous Conditions on Property
A property owner is notified of a broken fence around a pool that poses a safety hazard, but the owner does not repair it.
A landowner is told to remove hazardous debris or abandoned vehicles on their property but refuses to comply.
3. Rodent or Pest Infestations
A property owner allows garbage to pile up, attracting rats and other pests that spread to neighboring homes.
After being served notice, a landlord ignores complaints about unsanitary conditions leading to vermin infestations.
4. Illegal Dumping on Property
A property owner allows others to use their land as a dumping ground for garbage or hazardous materials, despite receiving written notice to clean it up.
5. Unsafe Residential Rentals
A landlord continues to rent units with severe code violations, such as faulty wiring or inadequate plumbing, even after being ordered to make repairs.
3. What are Common Defenses Against Penal Code § 372 & § 373a PC?
If you are charged with a public nuisance under Penal Code §§ 372 or 373a PC in California, it’s important to understand your legal options. These statutes make it a crime to create, maintain, or allow a public nuisance to persist, but several defenses can be used to challenge these accusations. Below are some of the most common defenses to public nuisance charges.
1. The Nuisance Was a One-Time Event
Under California law, a public nuisance must be a continuous or recurring issue. A single incident is not enough to constitute a public nuisance.
Example:
A tenant hosted a loud party one night, which caused noise complaints. If the tenant hasn’t had previous complaints or thrown similar parties, this is a one-time event and does not qualify as a public nuisance.
2. The Nuisance Did Not Affect a Community
To meet the legal definition of a public nuisance, the issue must impact a community, neighborhood, or a significant number of people. If the alleged nuisance only affected a small number of individuals, it may not meet this standard.
Example:
A property owner accidentally left construction materials on the sidewalk, which inconvenienced one or two passersby. This isolated complaint does not rise to the level of a public nuisance because it did not interfere with the enjoyment of the property for a broader community.
3. You Had No Knowledge of the Nuisance
For charges under Penal Code § 373a PC, the prosecution must prove that you knowingly allowed the public nuisance to exist on your property. If you were unaware of the nuisance or its impact, this could serve as a defense.
Example:
A landlord was out of state when tenants hosted a series of disruptive parties that led to complaints. If the landlord was unaware of the situation, they cannot be held liable under § 373a PC.
4. Lack of Written Notice
Under Penal Code § 373a PC, property owners must receive written notice from a health officer or city attorney that specifies the nuisance and requires corrective action. If you did not receive this notice, you cannot be held liable for failing to address the nuisance.
Example:
A property owner is accused of allowing trash to pile up on their land, but there is no record of them receiving written notice to resolve the issue. Without such notice, charges under § 373a PC cannot be upheld.
5. The Alleged Nuisance Did Not Meet Legal Standards
Not all offensive or disruptive conditions qualify as a public nuisance. The nuisance must meet specific legal criteria, such as:
Injuring someone’s health.
Offending public morals.
Interfering with the enjoyment of property.
If the alleged nuisance does not meet these requirements, the charges may not stand.
Example:
A resident uses bright outdoor lights on their property. While some neighbors find the lights annoying, they do not harm health, offend morals, or interfere significantly with property enjoyment. Therefore, the lights are unlikely to qualify as a public nuisance.
6. The Alleged Nuisance Was Beyond Your Control
In some cases, the alleged nuisance may have been caused by factors outside your control. If you can demonstrate that you took reasonable steps to prevent or remedy the nuisance, you may have a valid defense.
Example:
A landlord is notified about a rodent infestation in a rental property and immediately hires a pest control service to address the issue. Despite their efforts, the infestation persists due to external factors like nearby construction. The landlord cannot be held liable for the public nuisance.
7. Mistaken Identity
In some cases, you may be wrongly accused of causing or maintaining a public nuisance. If the nuisance was caused by someone else, such as a tenant or neighboring property owner, you cannot be held responsible.
Example:
A homeowner is accused of allowing illegal dumping on their property, but evidence shows that the dumping occurred on a neighbor’s land. In this case, the charges against the homeowner would not hold up.
our clients say it best
Client Testimonials
4. What are The Penalties for Violating Penal Code § 372 & § 373a PC?
Violating California Penal Code §§ 372 and 373a PC—laws concerning public nuisances—can result in serious legal consequences. These statutes aim to prevent activities or conditions that harm public health, interfere with property use, or disturb a community’s quality of life. If convicted, individuals face criminal penalties, but the extent of those penalties depends on the specific circumstances of the case.
Below, we’ll outline the penalties associated with violations of these laws and discuss additional considerations, such as expungements, immigration consequences, and gun rights.
Penalties for Penal Code § 372 & § 373a PC Violations
Both Penal Code § 372 and § 373a PC are charged as misdemeanors under California law. A conviction can result in:
County Jail Sentence
You may face up to six months in county jail.
Fines
You can be fined up to $1,000.
Probation
The court may impose misdemeanor probation (also called summary probation) instead of or in addition to jail time.
Probation conditions often include community service, payment of fines, and orders to address the nuisance.
Additional Legal Consequences
While the direct penalties for violating these statutes are limited to misdemeanor punishments, there are several additional legal considerations:
1. Expungement of Convictions
If you are convicted under these statutes, you may be eligible for an expungement under California Penal Code § 1203.4 PC.
Expungement allows you to withdraw your plea of guilty or no contest, and the case is dismissed from your record.
To qualify, you must complete your jail sentence or probation requirements.
2. Immigration Consequences
Public nuisance convictions under §§ 372 and 373a PC typically do not result in harmful immigration consequences.
These crimes are not considered deportable offenses or crimes involving moral turpitude.
3. Gun Rights
Since violations of these statutes are misdemeanors, a conviction will not affect your ability to own or possess firearms.
Felonies, not misdemeanors, generally result in the loss of gun rights.
Factors That May Impact Penalties
Several factors can influence the severity of your penalties if convicted of violating Penal Code §§ 372 or 373a PC:
Nature of the Nuisance
Penalties may be more severe if the nuisance caused significant harm to public health or safety, such as environmental hazards or serious injuries.
Repeat Offenses
A history of prior convictions may result in harsher penalties, including longer jail time or higher fines.
Failure to Comply with Written Notice
Under § 373a PC, knowingly failing to remedy a public nuisance after receiving written notice from a health officer or city attorney may aggravate the penalties.
Examples of Penalties in Practice
Example 1: Failure to Address Noise Complaints
A landlord fails to address ongoing noise complaints from tenants after receiving written notice. If convicted under Penal Code § 373a PC, they may be sentenced to three months in county jail and fined $500.
Example 2: Illegal Dumping on Public Property
A property owner allows construction debris to accumulate on public land, creating a health hazard. They could be convicted under Penal Code § 372 PC, sentenced to six months in jail, and fined $1,000.
Defending Against Public Nuisance Charges
If you are facing charges under Penal Code §§ 372 or 373a PC, several defenses may help you avoid penalties, including:
Proving the nuisance was a one-time event.
Demonstrating that the alleged nuisance did not impact a significant number of people.
Arguing that you were unaware of the nuisance or never received the required written notice.
Hiring an experienced criminal defense attorney can make a significant difference in building a strong defense and minimizing potential penalties.
5. What Are the Related Offenses To Penal Code § 372 & § 373a PC?
California Penal Code §§ 372 and 373a PC focus on public nuisance laws, targeting individuals who create or fail to address nuisances that harm a community’s health, safety, or quality of life. However, other offenses in California law address similar or related misconduct. These related crimes provide further legal frameworks for addressing disruptive, harmful, or unlawful activities.
Below, we’ll explore the offenses most closely related to Penal Code §§ 372 and 373a PC, along with their definitions, penalties, and key differences.
1. Penal Code § 415 PC – Disturbing the Peace
Definition:
Under Penal Code § 415 PC, you commit the offense of disturbing the peace if you:
Willfully fight another person in a public place.
Maliciously and willfully disturb another person with loud or unreasonable noise.
Use offensive words in public that are likely to provoke a violent reaction.
Relation to Public Nuisance Laws:
Disturbing the peace overlaps with public nuisance laws because both aim to protect public order and community wellbeing. However, PC § 415 focuses on specific, immediate disruptions, such as noise or fights, rather than ongoing or persistent nuisances.
Penalties:
Violations of PC § 415 are misdemeanors, punishable by:
Up to 90 days in county jail, and/or
A fine of up to $400.
2. Penal Code § 408 PC – Unlawful Assembly
Definition:
Penal Code § 408 PC prohibits two or more people from assembling with the intent to:
Engage in unlawful acts, or
Conduct legal activities in a violent, boisterous, or disruptive manner.
Relation to Public Nuisance Laws:
Unlawful assembly may involve behavior that creates or contributes to a public nuisance, such as blocking streets, vandalizing property, or disturbing a neighborhood. While PC § 372 and § 373a address ongoing nuisances, PC § 408 focuses on the immediate threat posed by the assembly.
Penalties:
Unlawful assembly is a misdemeanor, punishable by:
Up to six months in county jail, and/or
A fine of up to $1,000.
3. Penal Code § 374.3 PC – Illegal Dumping
Definition:
Penal Code § 374.3 PC makes it a crime to dispose of:
Garbage,
Waste, or
Other debris
on public or private property without permission.
Relation to Public Nuisance Laws:
Illegal dumping often creates a public nuisance by harming public health, safety, and aesthetics. For example, leaving hazardous materials on public land could be prosecuted under both PC § 374.3 and PC § 372.
Penalties:
Penalties for illegal dumping vary based on the circumstances:
Infraction: Fines ranging from $250 to $1,000.
Misdemeanor: Fines up to $3,000 for multiple violations and possible jail time.
4. Penal Code § 370 PC – Public Nuisance Definition
Definition:
Penal Code § 370 PC defines a public nuisance as anything that:
Injures someone’s health,
Offends community morals, or
Interferes with the free use of property.
Relation to Public Nuisance Laws:
PC § 370 serves as the foundational definition of what constitutes a public nuisance in California. Penal Code §§ 372 and 373a expand upon this definition by criminalizing the creation or maintenance of such nuisances.
5. California Civil Code § 3479 – Private Nuisance
Definition:
Civil Code § 3479 addresses private nuisances, which affect a specific individual or small group rather than an entire community. Examples include:
Excessive noise from a neighbor’s property, or
Tree roots damaging a neighbor’s foundation.
Relation to Public Nuisance Laws:
Private nuisances differ from public nuisances in their scope. While Penal Code §§ 372 and 373a target nuisances affecting communities, Civil Code § 3479 focuses on those impacting individuals.
Penalties:
Private nuisances are typically resolved through civil lawsuits, with remedies such as:
Injunctions to stop the nuisance.
Monetary damages to compensate the affected party.
6. Health and Safety Code § 117550 – Littering and Pollution
Definition:
This section prohibits littering and improper disposal of waste in public areas, including parks, waterways, and streets.
Relation to Public Nuisance Laws:
Improper waste disposal often contributes to public nuisances. For example, littering in a public park may be charged under both this health and safety code and PC § 372.
Penalties:
Violations can result in fines ranging from $100 to $1,000, depending on the severity and location of the offense.
Protecting Your Rights, Defending Your Future
Get in touch with our lawyers today to schedule a consultation and learn how we can help you. We are here to answer your questions and provide you with the support you need during this difficult time.
Client Satisfaction Is Priority
You Are More Than What They Say
We Always Go The Extra Mile