Penal Code § 422 PC - Criminal Threats
1. What is Penal Code § 422 PC?
Penal Code § 422 PC Law Reads As Followed:
The law states that any person who:
- Willfully threatens to commit a crime that would result in great bodily injury or death,
- Communicates the threat verbally, in writing, or electronically,
- Does so with the intent to cause fear,
- Creates a reasonable fear in the victim,
- Delivers the threat in a way that appears immediate, unconditional, and specific,
Shall be guilty of making a criminal threat, which can be charged as either a misdemeanor or felony.
2. What Are Examples of Penal Code § 422 PC?
Penal Code § 422 PC is California’s criminal threats law, designed to protect individuals from credible threats of death or serious bodily harm. These threats must cause the recipient to feel sustained and reasonable fear for their safety or the safety of their immediate family. While the law outlines specific criteria for what constitutes a criminal threat, understanding real-world examples can provide valuable clarity. Below are examples of actions that may qualify as violations of Penal Code § 422 PC.
1. Verbal Threats
A verbal statement can qualify as a criminal threat if it is explicit, credible, and causes the recipient to fear for their safety.
Example: During an argument, John tells his neighbor, “I’m going to come to your house tonight and kill you.” John’s neighbor, believing the threat to be credible, contacts the police. Because John’s statement was specific, immediate, and instilled fear, it could lead to charges under Penal Code § 422.
2. Written Threats
Threats made in writing, such as notes, letters, or text messages, can also violate Penal Code § 422 if they meet the legal criteria.
Example: A coworker leaves a note on someone’s desk that says, “Watch your back. You won’t survive the week.” The recipient believes the threat is serious and reports it to the authorities. The written nature of the threat and the victim’s fear make this a potential case of criminal threats.
3. Electronic Threats
Threats communicated through electronic devices, such as emails, social media posts, or text messages, often fall under Penal Code § 422.
Example: Sarah sends an email to her ex-partner that reads, “If I see you with anyone else, I’ll make sure you never walk again.” Her ex-partner feels threatened and files a police report. The email serves as evidence of Sarah’s intent, making this a potential criminal threat.
4. Threats Made Through a Third Party
A threat doesn’t have to be communicated directly to the victim to qualify under Penal Code § 422. Indirect threats made through a third party can also lead to charges.
Example: During a heated discussion, Mike tells his friend, “Tell your brother he’s dead if he doesn’t stay away from my family.” If the message is relayed to the brother and causes him to fear for his life, Mike could be charged with making a criminal threat.
5. Conditional Threats
Even threats that are conditional—tied to specific demands or circumstances—can be considered criminal if they create sustained and reasonable fear.
Example: A landlord tells a tenant, “If you don’t pay the rent by Friday, I’ll burn down your apartment.” Although conditional, the threat is specific and credible enough to cause fear, making it a potential violation of Penal Code § 422.
6. Threats Accompanied by a Weapon
A threat involving a weapon often escalates the seriousness of the offense and increases the likelihood of prosecution.
Example: During an argument at a gas station, a person displays a knife and says, “If you don’t leave now, I’ll stab you.” The visible weapon and explicit statement make this a clear example of a criminal threat.
7. Empty or Exaggerated Threats That Cause Fear
Even if the person making the threat has no intention or ability to carry it out, they can still face charges if the threat causes fear.
Example: A man shows an inoperable grenade to a store employee and says, “If you don’t give me all the money, I’ll blow this place up.” Despite the grenade being inoperable, the employee believes it to be real and feels terrified, making this an actionable criminal threat.
8. Threats in Domestic Violence Situations
Criminal threats often arise in the context of domestic disputes. These cases may involve specific threats of harm directed at a partner or family member.
Example: During an argument, a husband tells his wife, “If you try to leave me, I’ll kill you and take the kids.” The wife believes the threat and contacts law enforcement. The husband’s statement could lead to charges under Penal Code § 422.
9. Group or Public Threats
Threats directed at multiple people, such as coworkers or the public, can also violate Penal Code § 422.
Example: A disgruntled employee sends a group text to their coworkers saying, “Don’t come to work tomorrow. Something bad is going to happen.” If the coworkers interpret this as a credible threat, the sender could face criminal charges.
10. Threats Made to Witnesses
Threats intended to intimidate witnesses from testifying or cooperating with law enforcement can also qualify as criminal threats.
Example: A gang member tells a witness, “If you testify against me, you won’t live to see another day.” The specific and intimidating nature of the statement makes it a clear violation of Penal Code § 422.
3. What are Common Defenses Against Penal Code § 422 PC?
If you’ve been accused of violating Penal Code § 422 PC, also known as California’s criminal threats law, it’s critical to understand the possible defenses available to fight these charges. A conviction can lead to significant penalties, including jail time, fines, and long-term consequences for your reputation and rights. Fortunately, with the right legal strategy, it’s possible to challenge the charges and secure a favorable outcome. Below are the most common defenses against Penal Code § 422 charges.
1. The Threat Was Not Specific or Credible
One of the key elements of a criminal threats charge is that the threat must be clear, specific, and credible. A vague or ambiguous statement often does not meet this standard.
Example: Saying “You’ll regret this one day” during an argument might be interpreted as an angry remark rather than a serious, specific threat to someone’s safety.
A skilled defense attorney can argue that the alleged threat was too vague or lacked credibility to instill fear.
2. The Threat Was Not Immediate
For a statement to qualify as a criminal threat, it must convey a sense of immediacy. If the alleged threat did not indicate when or how it would be carried out, it may not meet the legal definition under Penal Code § 422.
Example: Telling someone, “I’ll get you someday,” does not communicate an immediate intent to act, making it less likely to be considered a criminal threat.
3. The Victim Did Not Feel Fear
The prosecution must prove that the alleged victim actually experienced sustained fear as a result of the threat. If the victim did not take the statement seriously or believed it was a joke, the charge may not stand.
Example: During an argument, someone sarcastically says, “I’ll blow up your car,” and the recipient laughs it off. If there is evidence that the alleged victim did not feel fear, the charges should be dismissed.
4. The Victim’s Fear Was Unreasonable
Even if the alleged victim claims they were fearful, the fear must be reasonable under the circumstances. A statement or action that would not cause a reasonable person to fear for their safety cannot be the basis for a conviction.
Example: A man jokingly waves a plastic toy gun while making a threatening comment. If it’s clear the toy gun could not cause harm and the fear was unreasonable, the defense can argue the charge does not meet the legal standard.
5. The Threat Was a Result of Free Speech
The First Amendment protects certain types of speech, including emotional outbursts or angry remarks made without the intent to cause fear. Penal Code § 422 does not apply to speech that is protected under the Constitution.
Example: An inmate tells a therapist during a counseling session that they feel like harming someone once released. If the statement is part of a therapeutic process and not intended as a credible threat, it is likely protected speech.
6. False Accusations
Criminal threats charges are often based on the word of the alleged victim, which makes them susceptible to false accusations. A jealous, angry, or spiteful individual may fabricate a threat to harm your reputation or gain an advantage in a personal dispute.
Example: An ex-partner accuses you of making threats to gain leverage in a custody or divorce case. Your attorney can challenge their credibility by uncovering inconsistencies, ulterior motives, or a lack of evidence.
7. Lack of Evidence
In many cases, there is insufficient evidence to prove the alleged threat. If there are no recordings, written communications, or eyewitness accounts, the prosecution may struggle to meet the burden of proof.
Example: The alleged victim claims you made a threatening statement, but there are no witnesses or recordings to support their claim. A defense attorney can argue that the evidence is insufficient to convict.
8. The Threat Was Not Communicated
Penal Code § 422 requires that the threat is communicated to the intended recipient, either directly or through a third party. If the threat was never actually conveyed to the victim, it cannot result in a conviction.
Example: You made an angry comment to yourself or in private that was never heard or seen by the alleged victim. This does not meet the criteria for criminal threats.
9. The Alleged Victim’s Fear Was Not Sustained
The fear experienced by the victim must be more than momentary or fleeting. If the alleged victim quickly dismissed the threat or was not impacted long-term, the charge may not hold up in court.
Example: During an argument, you make an aggressive comment, but the recipient immediately calms down and continues the conversation. This suggests the fear was not sustained and may not qualify as a criminal threat.
10. The Threat Was Conditional
Conditional threats, such as “If you don’t do this, I’ll harm you,” can sometimes fall outside the scope of Penal Code § 422, depending on the circumstances. Courts will evaluate whether the threat conveyed an immediate intent to act.
Example: Telling someone, “If you come back here, I’ll hurt you,” may be viewed as a conditional warning rather than a criminal threat.
our clients say it best
Client Testimonials
4. What are The Penalties for Violating Penal Code § 422 PC?
Penal Code § 422 PC, California’s criminal threats law, makes it illegal to threaten to kill or cause great bodily harm to another person if the threat is credible, causes fear, and meets other legal criteria. The penalties for violating this law can be severe, ranging from misdemeanor charges to felony convictions, depending on the circumstances of the offense and the defendant’s criminal history. Below, we explore the possible penalties and their long-term consequences.
Penal Code § 422 as a “Wobbler” Offense
Penal Code § 422 is a “wobbler” in California, meaning it can be charged as either a misdemeanor or a felony. The prosecution’s decision depends on:
The specifics of the alleged threat (e.g., whether a weapon was involved).
The victim’s fear and reaction.
The defendant’s prior criminal record.
Misdemeanor Penalties
If charged as a misdemeanor, the penalties for violating Penal Code § 422 include:
Jail time: Up to 1 year in county jail.
Fines: A maximum fine of $1,000.
Probation: Court-mandated probation, which may include counseling or anger management classes.
Other consequences: A 10-year prohibition on owning or possessing firearms.
Misdemeanor charges are typically pursued in less severe cases, such as when the threat was deemed less credible or the victim’s fear was minimal.
Felony Penalties
If charged as a felony, the penalties are significantly more severe and include:
Prison time: Up to 3 years in state prison.
Fines: A maximum fine of $10,000.
Strike offense: A felony conviction under Penal Code § 422 counts as a “strike” under California’s Three Strikes Law. This means:
A second felony conviction with a prior strike results in a doubled prison sentence.
A third felony conviction with two prior strikes results in a mandatory sentence of 25 years to life in prison.
Firearm prohibition: A lifetime ban on owning or possessing firearms.
Probation: Possible probation with conditions such as community service, restitution, or attendance in anger management programs.
Enhanced Penalties for Special Circumstances
Additional penalties can apply in specific situations:
Use of a Deadly Weapon: If the threat was made while using a dangerous or deadly weapon, the defendant faces an additional 1-year prison sentence.
Multiple Threats: Making threats to multiple individuals, on separate occasions, or with distinct objectives can result in separate charges and sentences for each threat.
Gang-Related Threats: If the criminal threat is gang-related, it may trigger harsher penalties under California’s gang enhancement laws, potentially adding years to the prison sentence.
Collateral Consequences
A conviction under Penal Code § 422 can also lead to significant collateral consequences beyond the immediate penalties, including:
Employment restrictions: Employers may hesitate to hire someone with a violent crime on their record.
Professional licenses: A conviction may lead to disciplinary actions, suspension, or revocation of professional licenses.
Immigration consequences: For non-citizens, a conviction under Penal Code § 422 may be classified as a crime involving moral turpitude (CIMT) or an aggravated felony, which can result in deportation or inadmissibility.
Restraining orders: The court may issue a restraining order prohibiting the defendant from contacting the victim or coming near their residence or workplace.
California’s Three Strikes Law
Felony convictions under Penal Code § 422 are considered “serious felonies” under California’s Three Strikes Law. This classification significantly increases the consequences of any subsequent felony convictions:
A second felony strike results in a doubled sentence.
A third felony strike carries a mandatory minimum sentence of 25 years to life in prison.
Strike convictions require offenders to serve at least 85% of their sentence before becoming eligible for parole.
Additional Court-Ordered Penalties
Judges may impose additional penalties depending on the circumstances of the case, such as:
Restitution: Payment to the victim for emotional or financial harm caused by the threat.
Anger management programs: Completion of counseling or anger management classes.
Restraining orders: A court order preventing contact with the victim or their family.
Factors That Influence Sentencing
When determining the appropriate penalties, courts consider several factors, including:
The severity of the threat.
The victim’s reaction and level of fear.
Whether a weapon was involved.
The defendant’s criminal history.
Whether the defendant shows remorse or takes responsibility.
5. What Are the Related Offenses To Penal Code § 422 PC?
Penal Code § 422 PC, which criminalizes threats of death or great bodily harm, often overlaps with other criminal charges. These related offenses frequently arise in cases involving domestic disputes, harassment, or acts of violence. Understanding these related offenses is crucial for anyone facing criminal threats charges, as they can result in additional penalties or alternative charges. Below, we outline some of the most common offenses related to Penal Code § 422 PC.
1. Penal Code § 136.1 PC – Dissuading a Witness or Victim
This law makes it illegal to attempt to prevent or discourage a witness or victim from reporting a crime, testifying, or cooperating with law enforcement. Threats aimed at silencing witnesses or victims can lead to charges under both Penal Code § 422 and § 136.1.
Example: Telling someone, “If you testify against me, you’ll regret it,” could lead to charges for both criminal threats and dissuading a witness.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor: Up to 1 year in jail.
Felony: Up to 4 years in state prison.
2. Penal Code § 646.9 PC – Stalking
Stalking involves willfully harassing or threatening another person to the point where they fear for their safety or the safety of their family. Criminal threats often accompany stalking behavior, especially in domestic violence cases.
Example: Repeatedly sending threatening text messages to an ex-partner, causing them to fear physical harm, could result in charges for both stalking and criminal threats.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor: Up to 1 year in jail.
Felony: Up to 5 years in prison.
3. Penal Code § 243(e)(1) PC – Domestic Battery
Domestic battery is a common charge in cases involving threats against intimate partners or family members. If a criminal threat is made during a domestic dispute, additional charges for domestic battery may apply.
Example: During an argument, a person threatens their partner with harm and follows up with physical contact. The threats could lead to charges under Penal Code § 422, while the physical act could lead to a domestic battery charge.
Penalties:
Up to 1 year in county jail and fines up to $2,000.
4. Penal Code § 273.5 PC – Corporal Injury on a Spouse or Cohabitant
Corporal injury on a spouse or cohabitant occurs when someone willfully inflicts physical harm on an intimate partner. Criminal threats made during or before an act of physical violence can result in multiple charges.
Example: Threatening to harm a partner before physically attacking them could lead to charges under both Penal Code § 422 and § 273.5.
Penalties:
Felony: Up to 4 years in state prison.
5. Penal Code § 273.6 PC – Violating a Restraining Order
If a criminal threat violates a court-issued restraining order, such as one issued in a domestic violence case, the defendant may face charges under Penal Code § 273.6 in addition to Penal Code § 422.
Example: A person threatens their ex-partner in violation of a restraining order issued after a prior domestic violence case.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor: Up to 1 year in jail.
Felony: Up to 3 years in prison.
6. Penal Code § 518 PC – Extortion
Extortion, also known as blackmail, involves using threats to coerce someone into giving money, property, or something of value. When the threat involves harm or violence, extortion and criminal threats charges may both apply.
Example: Telling someone, “If you don’t pay me $10,000, I’ll harm your family,” could result in extortion and criminal threats charges.
Penalties:
Felony: Up to 4 years in state prison.
7. Penal Code § 601 PC – Aggravated Trespass
Aggravated trespass involves unlawfully entering someone’s property with the intent to carry out a threat of physical harm. This offense often overlaps with criminal threats when someone threatens violence and then attempts to act on it.
Example: Threatening to harm a coworker and showing up at their home with a weapon.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor: Up to 1 year in jail.
Felony: Up to 3 years in prison.
8. Penal Code § 653m PC – Annoying or Harassing Phone Calls
Repeatedly making phone calls or sending messages with the intent to annoy, harass, or threaten someone can lead to charges under Penal Code § 653m. When the content of the calls or messages includes credible threats, additional charges for criminal threats may apply.
Example: Calling someone multiple times a day and threatening to harm them during each call.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor: Up to 6 months in jail.
9. Penal Code § 664/187 PC – Attempted Murder
If a criminal threat escalates to an attempt to carry out the act, the defendant may face attempted murder charges. This is among the most serious related offenses to Penal Code § 422.
Example: Telling someone, “I’m going to kill you,” and then attempting to physically attack them.
Penalties:
Felony: Up to 9 years in state prison, depending on the circumstances.
10. Cyber Threats and Cyber Harassment
With the rise of electronic communication, threats made via social media, email, or other online platforms may lead to charges under Penal Code § 422 for criminal threats, as well as additional charges for cyber harassment.
Example: Posting a message on social media threatening to harm a coworker, causing them to feel fear for their safety.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor or Felony: Depending on the severity of the case, penalties may include fines, jail, or prison time.
Protecting Your Rights, Defending Your Future
Get in touch with our lawyers today to schedule a consultation and learn how we can help you. We are here to answer your questions and provide you with the support you need during this difficult time.
Client Satisfaction Is Priority
You Are More Than What They Say
We Always Go The Extra Mile