Penal Code § 166 PC - Contempt of Court

Table of contents

Click To travel To Chapters

1. What is Penal Code § 166 PC?

California Penal Code 166 PC addresses contempt of court, which occurs when an individual willfully disobeys a court order or engages in behavior that disrupts the court’s proceedings. This law ensures that the judicial process operates smoothly and that court orders are respected and followed. Violating Penal Code 166 PC is a misdemeanor offense that can lead to fines, jail time, or both.

What Constitutes Contempt of Court Under Penal Code 166 PC?

Contempt of court includes a variety of behaviors that undermine the authority or dignity of the court. Some examples of conduct prohibited under Penal Code 166 PC include:

Disruptive Behavior in Court
- Being noisy or engaging in disorderly conduct while court is in session.
- Breaching the peace or disrespecting court officials.
Willful Disobedience of a Court Order
- Violating a restraining order or protective order issued by the court.
- Ignoring the terms of a lawful injunction.
Refusing to Testify or Cooperate as a Witness
- Refusing to be sworn in as a witness.
- Failing to answer material questions without a legal basis.
Publishing False Accounts of Court Proceedings
- Willfully spreading inaccurate or misleading information about a court case.
Violations of Protective Orders
- Disobeying stay-away orders related to cases involving domestic violence, elder abuse, or dependent adult abuse.

Key Legal Elements of Penal Code 166 PC

To convict someone of contempt of court under Penal Code 166 PC, the prosecution must prove the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

A Legal Court Order or Rule Existed
- The order must have been issued by a court with jurisdiction over the matter.
The Defendant Was Aware of the Court Order
- The individual must have known about the order and had the opportunity to read or understand it.
The Defendant Had the Ability to Comply
- The person must have been physically and practically capable of following the court order.
The Defendant Willfully Disobeyed or Violated the Order
- The act must have been intentional, not accidental or due to misunderstanding.

Penal Code § 166 PC Law Reads As Followed:

(a) Every person who, having been directed by the court, either by a written order or otherwise, to do or refrain from doing any act, willfully disobeys such order is guilty of contempt of court.

(b) A person is also guilty of contempt if, in the course of a judicial proceeding, they willfully engage in disrespectful or disorderly behavior, disturb the proceedings, or fail to comply with a lawful order of the court. This includes such conduct as shouting, taunting, or refusing to testify when summoned.

2. What Are Examples of Penal Code § 166 PC?

California Penal Code § 166 PC addresses contempt of court, a legal term that refers to any action that disrupts the orderly function of the court or disobeys a lawful court order. Contempt of court can take many forms, and the behavior that constitutes contempt is explicitly defined under California law. In this article, we will explore the most common examples of Penal Code § 166 PC, helping you understand what actions might lead to a contempt charge.

1. Disruptive Behavior During Court Proceedings

One of the most common examples of Penal Code § 166 PC is disorderly conduct during a court session. This can include:

Being Loud or Obnoxious: Shouting or speaking out of turn in a courtroom can disrupt the proceedings and may be considered contempt.
Interrupting the Court: If you disrupt the judge or other parties during their statements, you may be found in contempt.
Taunting or Mocking: Disrespectful actions toward the judge, attorneys, or others involved in the case, such as taunting the court staff or making inappropriate comments, can result in contempt charges.

Example: A person who repeatedly shouts at the judge or laughs loudly while someone else is speaking in court could be charged with contempt of court under PC 166.

2. Failure to Comply with Court Orders

One of the most serious types of contempt of court occurs when an individual willfully disobeys a lawful court order. This could involve:

Not Following a Restraining Order: Violating the terms of a domestic violence protective order, child custody order, or other court orders related to personal conduct.
Ignoring Child Support Orders: Failing to make required child support payments as directed by the court could be considered contempt.
Refusing to Comply with Injunctions: Disobeying a court injunction (a court-ordered restriction) can lead to contempt charges.

Example: If a person has been ordered by the court to stay away from a specific individual due to a restraining order but violates this order by contacting or visiting the individual, they could be charged with contempt.

3. Refusal to Testify or Answer Questions in Court

Another common example under PC 166 is when a person refuses to comply with legal procedures during a court hearing or trial, such as:

Refusing to Take an Oath: If you are subpoenaed as a witness and refuse to swear in or take an oath, this is a form of contempt.
Refusal to Answer Questions: If you are a witness in a trial and refuse to answer questions that are material to the case, and you have no legal right to remain silent (such as invoking the Fifth Amendment), this could be contempt.

Example: During a trial, if a witness refuses to testify about key details, despite being ordered by the judge to do so, the court may charge that individual with contempt under PC 166.

4. Publishing False Statements About Court Proceedings

Contempt of court also includes the act of publishing false accounts of court proceedings. This can undermine the judicial process and mislead the public. Actions that may lead to contempt under this provision include:

Falsely Reporting Court Proceedings: If someone publishes or broadcasts a completely false or misleading account of what occurred in a courtroom, this can be considered contempt.
Disrupting Court Records: Altering or destroying official court records or documents could result in contempt charges.

Example: A media outlet publishes a fabricated report about what transpired in a courtroom, intentionally distorting the facts, and this could be seen as contempt of court.

5. Violation of a Protective or Restraining Order

Violating any protective order issued by the court is considered a form of contempt of court. These violations can include:

Domestic Violence Restraining Orders: Ignoring the conditions of a restraining order issued due to domestic violence allegations.
Elder Abuse Restraining Orders: Failing to abide by an elder abuse restraining order.
Child Abuse or Dependent Adult Abuse Orders: Disobeying orders related to the protection of minors or dependent adults.

Example: If a person under a restraining order for domestic violence enters the protected person’s home or contacts them in violation of the order, they could be charged with contempt of court.

6. Disrespecting Court Staff or Officials

While less common, showing disrespect for court officials, such as the court clerk or bailiff, can lead to contempt charges. This can include:

Taunting or Abusing Court Personnel: Verbal abuse or physical aggression toward any court staff member.
Refusal to Cooperate with Court Staff: Not following instructions from court officials or refusing to cooperate during court proceedings.

Example: An individual who insults or threatens a bailiff during a courtroom session could be charged with contempt of court.

7. Failure to Appear in Court (Failure to Appear for a Hearing or Trial)

In some instances, failing to appear in court when required can result in contempt charges, especially if the absence is willful and intentional. Failure to appear is typically a separate charge, but it can be related to contempt if it is seen as a refusal to comply with a lawful order from the court.

Example: A person who intentionally skips a court-ordered appearance or hearing, without a valid reason or legal exemption, may face contempt charges.

3. What are Common Defenses Against Penal Code § 166 PC?

California Penal Code § 166 PC defines contempt of court, which involves willfully disobeying court orders or engaging in disruptive conduct during legal proceedings. A conviction under this statute can lead to serious consequences, including jail time, fines, and a criminal record. However, individuals charged with contempt of court have several potential defenses they can use to fight the charges. Understanding these defenses is crucial to ensuring that you have the best possible chance of avoiding conviction.

In this article, we will explore some of the most common defenses against charges of Penal Code § 166 PC, so that you can better understand how to protect your rights in the face of a contempt accusation.

1. No Willful Violation of a Court Order

Under Penal Code § 166, one of the key elements prosecutors must prove is that the violation of the court order was willful. This means that the defendant intentionally or knowingly disregarded the court’s order.

If you can demonstrate that the violation of the court order was not willful, then you may have a strong defense. Examples where a violation may not be willful include:

Accidental Violation: If you unintentionally failed to comply with a court order, such as missing a scheduled court date due to a genuine emergency or misunderstanding, you may not be guilty of contempt.
Inability to Comply: In some cases, an individual may be unable to comply with a court order due to factors outside their control, such as illness, financial inability, or lack of knowledge about the order.

Example: If a court orders a person to make a payment, but the person is unable to do so because they lost their job and cannot afford the payment, they might be able to argue that they did not willfully violate the order.

2. No Disorderly Conduct

Another common defense against Penal Code § 166 charges is the argument that the behavior in question did not rise to the level of disorderly conduct. The law specifically prohibits disruptive behavior in court, but not all behavior that is slightly out of the norm constitutes contempt.

In cases where the individual’s conduct was not particularly egregious or disruptive, a defense attorney might argue that:

The Behavior Was Not Disorderly: The actions did not interfere with or disrupt the proceedings of the court. For example, a minor outburst might not be considered severe enough to qualify as contempt.
The Behavior Was Justified: If the defendant acted in a manner that they believed was necessary for a valid reason (for example, standing up to object to false testimony), it may not constitute contempt.

Example: A person who briefly raised their voice to clarify a misunderstanding in court may argue that their conduct did not disrupt the proceedings or interfere with the court’s function.

3. Falsely Accused

False accusations are a common defense in contempt of court cases, especially when the defendant is accused of violating a court order or engaging in disruptive behavior. This can occur in situations where:

Personal Conflict: A party involved in the case might falsely accuse someone of contempt as a way of retaliating or getting back at them. This is particularly common in divorce or family law cases, where there may be animosity between the parties.
Misunderstanding of the Court Order: Sometimes, people are accused of violating court orders when there was a misunderstanding or miscommunication about the terms of the order.

Example: In a contentious custody battle, one party may falsely accuse the other of contempt simply because the other parent accidentally missed a scheduled visit. If this claim is made maliciously or out of spite, it could be challenged as a false accusation.

4. No Knowledge of the Court Order

For someone to be charged with contempt under Penal Code § 166, they must have had knowledge of the court order they are accused of violating. If a defendant was not aware of the order or never received proper notice, they may not be guilty of contempt.

Common situations where lack of knowledge may be a defense include:

Failure to Receive the Order: If the defendant was never properly served with the court order or failed to receive it, they may argue that they were unaware of its existence.
No Opportunity to Comply: If the defendant never had a reasonable opportunity to comply with the order—such as receiving an order only shortly before a deadline—they may not be held responsible.

Example: If a defendant was not properly notified of a court order to stay away from a specific person and later interacts with that person unintentionally, they may have a valid defense based on lack of knowledge.

5. The Order Was Not Lawful

In some cases, the court order itself may be invalid or unlawful. If a defendant can show that the court order they are accused of violating was not legally issued, they may be able to argue that no contempt occurred.

This defense may apply if:

The Order Was Too Vague or Unclear: If the terms of the court order were ambiguous or unclear, it may be unreasonable to expect the defendant to comply with it.
The Order Was Issued Without Proper Jurisdiction: If the court had no legal authority to issue the order in the first place, the defendant could argue that there was no legal obligation to follow it.

Example: If a court order requiring a person to stay away from a location was unclear about the boundaries of the protected area, the defendant could argue that they didn’t know how to comply.

6. The Charge Was Based on False Testimony or Evidence

If the charges for contempt of court stem from false testimony or inaccurate evidence, the defendant can argue that the accusation is invalid. For example, if someone lied under oath about your behavior during court proceedings, this could lead to an unjust contempt charge.

Example: If someone testifies that a defendant was disrespectful or disruptive in court, but video evidence shows that the defendant behaved appropriately, the charge could be contested.

our clients say it best

Client Testimonials

4. What are The Penalties for Violating Penal Code § 166 PC?

California Penal Code § 166 PC makes it a criminal offense to engage in contempt of court. This includes willfully disobeying court orders or engaging in disruptive behavior during legal proceedings. While contempt of court may seem like a minor infraction, it can carry serious penalties that can impact your freedom, finances, and future.

In this article, we will explore the potential penalties for violating Penal Code § 166 PC, including jail time, fines, and other consequences. We will also discuss factors that may influence the severity of the penalties and how an experienced criminal defense attorney can help mitigate the consequences of a conviction.

1. Misdemeanor Penalties for Contempt of Court

In most cases, violating Penal Code § 166 is classified as a misdemeanor, which is the least serious category of criminal offenses. However, even though it is considered a misdemeanor, a conviction for contempt of court can still result in significant penalties.

The standard penalties for misdemeanor contempt include:

Up to 6 months in county jail: If convicted of contempt of court, the defendant could face a jail sentence of up to six months in a county jail. This is not the same as state prison; the sentence is typically served in a local county jail.
Fines up to $1,000: In addition to potential jail time, a conviction under Penal Code § 166 PC may result in a fine of up to $1,000. The court may impose the fine alone or in conjunction with jail time.

These penalties reflect the seriousness with which the state treats contempt of court. However, there are certain factors that may lead to more severe penalties, which we will discuss in the next section.

2. Aggravating Factors That May Lead to Harsher Penalties

In some situations, the penalties for violating Penal Code § 166 PC can be more severe, especially if certain aggravating factors are present. For example, if the violation involves additional offenses or shows a pattern of disregard for the court’s authority, the penalties may increase.

Common aggravating factors that could lead to harsher penalties include:

Violation of a Domestic Violence Protective Order: If the contempt involves the violation of a domestic violence restraining order, the penalties can be more severe. This may include additional jail time or a fine exceeding the standard maximum for contempt of court.
Repeat Violations: A defendant with prior convictions for contempt of court, especially those involving acts of violence or threats of violence, may face a more severe penalty for subsequent violations. In some cases, this can result in a jail sentence that exceeds six months or an increased fine.
Violating a Court Order Involving Children: If the contempt involves a court order related to child custody or child support, it may be viewed more seriously, and the defendant could face higher penalties due to the importance of protecting children’s well-being.
Violation of a Firearm Restriction: If the court order involved a firearm restriction, such as a ban on possessing firearms, the penalty could be more severe. For example, if a defendant violates a court order prohibiting them from possessing a firearm, they could face increased penalties for contempt.

Felony Violation of Penal Code § 166 PC

In certain circumstances, contempt of court can be charged as a felony rather than a misdemeanor. This typically happens when the violation is connected to more serious offenses or involves specific types of court orders.

For instance, if the defendant has a history of violating restraining orders or has committed an act of violence during a violation, the charges may be elevated to a felony. A felony conviction for contempt of court can result in:

State prison sentence: A felony conviction can lead to a state prison sentence, which is far more serious than a county jail sentence. Felony contempt of court charges may result in a prison sentence ranging from 16 months to 3 years, depending on the severity of the offense.
Longer probation terms: A felony conviction can also lead to a longer probation period, with stricter conditions that may include regular check-ins with a probation officer, drug testing, and restrictions on travel.
Increased fines: Felony convictions may come with larger fines that can reach several thousand dollars, in addition to the costs of incarceration and probation.

3. Alternative Sentencing Options

While jail time and fines are the typical penalties for violating Penal Code § 166 PC, there are some alternative sentencing options that a judge may impose. These options can vary depending on the circumstances of the case and the defendant’s criminal history.

Misdemeanor (or Summary) Probation: In lieu of serving time in jail, a judge may impose probation, especially for first-time offenders or those who have no history of violent conduct. Probation is a type of supervision that allows the defendant to remain in the community under specific conditions, such as regular check-ins with a probation officer, attending counseling, or completing community service. The defendant may still face fines or other penalties while on probation.
Community Service: In some cases, a judge may allow the defendant to complete community service in lieu of a fine or jail time. Community service is often seen as a more rehabilitative option for non-violent offenders.
Jail Alternatives: For individuals who are sentenced to jail time, there may be alternative options available, such as electronic monitoring or house arrest. These options allow the defendant to serve their sentence in the community under supervision rather than being incarcerated in a jail facility.

4. Other Consequences of a Contempt Conviction

In addition to jail time, fines, and probation, there are other long-term consequences that may result from a Penal Code § 166 PC conviction. These include:

Criminal Record: A conviction for contempt of court will appear on the defendant’s criminal record, which can affect their future employment prospects, housing options, and social standing.
Immigration Consequences: While a Penal Code § 166 PC conviction is generally not considered an aggravated felony under immigration law, it can still have immigration consequences for non-citizens. Depending on the circumstances, a conviction could affect the defendant’s immigration status or make them ineligible for certain benefits.
Impact on Gun Rights: Although contempt of court convictions typically do not affect gun rights, if the court order involved a restriction on firearms, the defendant could lose the right to possess guns. This is especially true if the violation involves a domestic violence restraining order.

5. What Are the Related Offenses To Penal Code § 166 PC?

Penal Code § 166 PC addresses contempt of court, which occurs when an individual disobeys a court order, disrupts court proceedings, or engages in disorderly conduct during a court session. While Penal Code § 166 PC specifically deals with contempt, several other criminal offenses are closely related to contempt of court, either because they involve similar conduct or because they stem from a defendant’s disregard for court orders. Understanding these related offenses is important, as they can carry serious legal consequences and may be charged alongside or instead of contempt of court.

In this article, we will explore some of the related offenses to Penal Code § 166 PC, including their definitions, penalties, and the connections between these offenses and contempt of court.

1. Violation of a Restraining Order – Penal Code § 273.6 PC

One of the most common offenses related to Penal Code § 166 PC is the violation of a restraining order under Penal Code § 273.6 PC. Restraining orders are legal orders issued by a court to protect individuals from abuse, harassment, or threats, and they may include directives to stay away from a specific person, location, or type of conduct.

Key Elements of Penal Code § 273.6 PC:

Knowing Violation of a Restraining Order: A person can be charged with violating a restraining order if they knowingly disobey the terms set by the court. For example, if a person subject to a domestic violence restraining order visits the protected party’s home or contacts them against the court’s orders, they can be charged under this statute.
Penalties: A violation of Penal Code § 273.6 PC is typically classified as a misdemeanor, punishable by up to one year in county jail, a fine, or both. However, violations of restraining orders related to domestic violence, elder abuse, or child abuse may result in more severe penalties, including longer jail sentences.