Penal Code § 417.4 PC - Brandishing an Imitation Firearm
Table of contents
Click To travel To Chapters
1. What is Penal Code § 417.4 PC?
Penal Code § 417.4 PC Law Reads As Followed:
“Every person who, except in self-defense, draws or exhibits an imitation firearm, as defined in Section 417.4, in a threatening manner against another person in such a way as to cause a reasonable person apprehension or fear of bodily harm is guilty of a misdemeanor.”
2. What are Examples of Penal Code § 417.4 PC?
California Penal Code § 417.4 PC makes it illegal to brandish an imitation firearm in a threatening manner, causing a reasonable person to fear bodily harm. The law is intended to prevent situations where a person uses a fake gun to intimidate or scare others, even if the firearm isn’t real. Below are some real-world examples that would violate Penal Code § 417.4 PC:
Example 1: A Prank Gone Wrong
Jason and his friends decide to play a prank on their neighbor, using a realistic-looking toy gun. Jason pulls out the imitation firearm and points it at his neighbor while shouting aggressively. The neighbor, believing the gun to be real, is terrified and calls the police. Despite the gun being a toy, Jason can be charged under Penal Code § 417.4 for brandishing the imitation firearm in a way that caused the neighbor to reasonably fear for their safety.
Example 2: Road Rage Incident
During a road rage incident, Maria becomes frustrated with another driver. She pulls over, gets out of her car, and pulls what appears to be a handgun from her bag. Although the gun is a BB gun and not capable of causing serious injury, the other driver perceives it as a real firearm and fears for their life. Maria’s display of the imitation firearm in a threatening manner would likely result in charges under PC § 417.4, as it caused the driver to reasonably fear bodily harm.
Example 3: Intimidation During an Argument
During an argument outside of a bar, Paul pulls out what looks like a firearm to intimidate a group of people. Even though it is an airsoft gun, it looks real, and the group fears for their safety. Paul never fires the imitation firearm, but its display causes enough fear to warrant charges under Penal Code § 417.4 for brandishing the imitation firearm.
Example 4: Shoplifting with a Fake Gun
Sarah is caught shoplifting and, in an attempt to escape, pulls out what looks like a firearm and points it at a store employee. The employee, thinking it is a real gun, lets Sarah go out of fear for their safety. Even though the firearm is later discovered to be a toy, Sarah can still face charges under Penal Code § 417.4 for using the fake gun in a way that caused the store employee to fear bodily harm.
Example 5: Argument in Public
While in a public park, Ken and his friends get into a heated argument with another group. To assert dominance and scare the other group, Ken pulls out an airsoft gun, which looks very much like a real firearm. The other group is terrified and leaves the park immediately. Ken’s actions would fall under Penal Code § 417.4 because he used the imitation firearm in a manner that made the other group reasonably fear harm, even though the gun was not real.
3. What are The Common Defenses Against Penal Code § 417.4 PC?
California Penal Code § 417.4 PC makes it a crime to brandish an imitation firearm in a threatening manner, causing someone to reasonably fear for their safety. Although the firearm may be fake, the legal consequences can be very real. Fortunately, there are several legal defenses that may help in fighting a Penal Code § 417.4 charge. Below are the most common defenses used to challenge this accusation:
1. No Threatening Act
One of the key elements of Penal Code § 417.4 is that the imitation firearm must be exhibited in a threatening manner. If the prosecution cannot prove that the accused person’s actions were threatening, the charge may not stand. For example, if the imitation firearm was displayed jokingly, theatrically, or without the intent to cause harm, it may not meet the legal standard for “brandishing.”
Example:
John pulls out a toy gun during a party, joking with friends in a clearly non-threatening way. However, someone nearby misinterprets his actions and feels scared. Since John did not act in a threatening manner, he could argue that there was no intent to cause fear, which may serve as a valid defense.
2. No Reasonable Fear
Another crucial element of Penal Code § 417.4 is that the act must have caused the alleged victim to fear for their safety. This fear must be “reasonable,” meaning that a typical person in the same situation would have felt threatened. If the victim’s fear was irrational or not grounded in the circumstances, this can be a strong defense.
Example:
Sarah pulls out a brightly colored toy gun with a cartoon design while sitting in a park. A passerby, despite the toy’s obvious non-threatening appearance, claims they were scared. In this case, Sarah’s defense could be that a reasonable person would not have mistaken her toy gun for a real firearm, and the fear was not justified.
3. The Imitation Firearm Was Not Displayed
If the accused never actually displayed the imitation firearm in a public or threatening way, it’s possible to argue that Penal Code § 417.4 was not violated. Simply possessing an imitation firearm does not violate the law; it only becomes illegal when brandished in a way that causes fear.
Example:
Mike carries an imitation firearm in his backpack for use in a film project. During an argument with a friend, he never takes the toy gun out of his bag or uses it to threaten anyone. Since Mike never exhibited the imitation firearm, he should not be found guilty of brandishing under PC § 417.4.
4. Self-Defense or Defense of Others
Under California law, a person is allowed to brandish an imitation firearm if they are acting in self-defense or defense of someone else. The defense must show that the accused reasonably believed they or someone else was in imminent danger of bodily harm and that brandishing the imitation firearm was a reasonable response to that threat.
Example:
Lisa is walking home when she is approached by someone acting aggressively. Fearing for her safety, she pulls out an airsoft gun that looks like a real firearm to scare off the attacker. If Lisa reasonably believed she was in danger and the imitation gun was used to prevent harm, this could be a valid defense.
5. The Act Was an Accident
If the imitation firearm was drawn or displayed accidentally, without any intent to cause fear or harm, the charge of brandishing under Penal Code § 417.4 may not apply. Accidental acts lack the willful intent required to sustain a conviction under this statute.
Example:
Tom is moving items from his car when an imitation gun falls out of a box in front of a bystander. The bystander feels startled and calls the police. Since Tom did not intentionally display the imitation firearm in a threatening manner, he could argue that the display was purely accidental.
6. The Firearm Was Not an Imitation
For a person to be convicted under Penal Code § 417.4, the item in question must be an “imitation firearm.” If the object does not closely resemble a real firearm in color and appearance, it may not legally qualify as an imitation firearm under the statute. In this case, the accused can argue that what was brandished was not an imitation firearm as defined by law.
Example:
Emily waves a brightly colored water pistol while playing with friends in a public park. Since the water gun is not a realistic-looking imitation firearm, it may not meet the legal definition of an imitation firearm under PC § 417.4.
our clients say it best
Client Testimonials
4. What are The Penalties for Violating Penal Code § 417.4 PC?
In California, Penal Code § 417.4 PC makes it a crime to brandish an imitation firearm in a threatening manner. Even though the firearm is fake, the law treats the act seriously because it can cause real fear and panic. If you are convicted of violating Penal Code § 417.4, the penalties can be significant. Below is a breakdown of the potential consequences for this misdemeanor offense.
1. Misdemeanor Offense
Violating Penal Code § 417.4 PC is classified as a misdemeanor under California law. This means that, while it is not as severe as a felony, the consequences can still have a lasting impact on your life, including jail time, fines, and a criminal record.
2. Jail Time
If convicted of brandishing an imitation firearm, you could face imprisonment in county jail for a period ranging from 30 days to 6 months. The minimum 30-day jail sentence is required, meaning that a conviction under this statute almost always results in some jail time, even if it’s just a brief period.
Example:
Mark draws an airsoft gun during a heated argument in a public park, causing bystanders to panic and call the police. If convicted under Penal Code § 417.4, Mark could face up to six months in county jail due to the threatening nature of his actions.
3. Fines
In addition to potential jail time, Penal Code § 417.4 PC violations can result in a fine. The fine can go up to $1,000, depending on the circumstances of the case and the judge’s discretion. The court may also impose additional court costs and administrative fees as part of the sentencing.
Example:
Lisa threatens someone by brandishing a realistic-looking BB gun during a road rage incident. Along with a possible jail sentence, Lisa could be fined up to $1,000 for violating Penal Code § 417.4.
4. Probation
In some cases, instead of imposing jail time, the judge may sentence you to probation. This is often referred to as “misdemeanor probation” or “summary probation.” Probation allows you to avoid jail time, but it comes with strict conditions that must be followed.
Conditions of probation may include:
Regular check-ins with a probation officer
Attending anger management classes or counseling
Community service
Payment of fines and restitution
Staying away from the victim or location of the incident
If you violate the terms of your probation, you could be sent to jail to serve the original sentence.
Example:
Steve points a realistic toy gun at a friend during a prank, but someone witnessing the incident feels threatened and calls the police. If Steve is convicted, the judge may choose to sentence him to probation instead of jail time, provided he meets all the probation requirements.
5. Expungement
If you are convicted of brandishing an imitation firearm under Penal Code § 417.4, you may be eligible to have your conviction expunged from your record under Penal Code § 1203.4 PC. Expungement means that, after successfully completing your sentence, including probation, you can petition the court to remove the conviction from your criminal record.
This can be especially beneficial for future employment opportunities or housing applications, as an expunged conviction does not need to be disclosed in most situations.
Example:
After serving probation for brandishing an imitation firearm, Claire completes all the conditions of her sentence. She can then apply for an expungement, which, if granted, will remove the conviction from her criminal record, allowing her to move forward without the stigma of a criminal offense.
6. Impact on Employment and Licensing
Even though Penal Code § 417.4 PC is a misdemeanor, a conviction can still have significant consequences on your employment, especially if you work in professions that require background checks or licensing. Employers may view any brandishing charge—real or imitation firearm—as a violent offense, making it difficult to obtain or maintain certain jobs.
Some professional licenses, including those in healthcare, education, and security, may be revoked or denied if you are convicted of a crime involving threatening behavior.
7. Firearm Rights
Since Penal Code § 417.4 involves an imitation firearm rather than a real one, it typically does not result in the loss of firearm rights, unlike more serious firearm-related crimes. However, a misdemeanor conviction can still impact background checks and certain permits or licenses.
5. What are The Related Offenses To Penal Code § 417.4 PC?
Penal Code § 417.4 PC, which makes it a crime to brandish an imitation firearm in a threatening manner, has several related offenses under California law. These offenses deal with similar acts of threatening behavior involving firearms, deadly weapons, or other intimidating objects. While each of these crimes is distinct, they all revolve around actions that can create fear or the perception of danger in others. Below, we’ll explore some of the most common related offenses to Penal Code § 417.4 PC.
1. Penal Code § 417 PC – Brandishing a Weapon or Firearm
One of the most closely related offenses to Penal Code § 417.4 is Penal Code § 417, which makes it a crime to brandish a real firearm or deadly weapon. While § 417.4 applies specifically to imitation firearms, § 417 covers the use of real weapons. Under this statute, you can be charged with a crime if you exhibit or draw a deadly weapon or firearm in a rude, angry, or threatening manner, or if you use a weapon during a fight.
Penalties:
For brandishing a firearm in public, you may face jail time of at least 30 days.
For brandishing a firearm in the presence of a peace officer, the penalties can be more severe.
If the crime involves the use of a real weapon, the consequences can include fines, jail time, or both.
Example:
Liam brandishes a real handgun during an argument with another driver on the freeway. He may be charged under Penal Code § 417 for brandishing a firearm, which carries more serious penalties than brandishing an imitation firearm.
2. Penal Code § 245(a)(2) PC – Assault with a Firearm
Penal Code § 245(a)(2) makes it a crime to commit assault with a firearm. Unlike brandishing under § 417 or § 417.4, which only requires displaying a weapon in a threatening manner, assault with a firearm involves actually using or attempting to use the firearm to commit a violent act.
Assault with a firearm is a more serious offense and can result in significant penalties, including state prison time.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor assault with a firearm is punishable by up to one year in county jail.
Felony assault with a firearm can result in 2, 3, or 4 years in state prison.
Example:
During a heated argument, Ethan fires a handgun at a rival but misses. He can be charged with assault with a firearm under Penal Code § 245(a)(2), even if no one was injured.
3. Penal Code § 417.25 PC – Pointing a Laser Scope or Laser Pointer
Penal Code § 417.25 PC makes it illegal to aim a laser scope or pointer at another person in a threatening manner. Laser scopes are often mounted on firearms, and while this law doesn’t specifically involve imitation guns, it deals with the intent to create fear by pointing what may appear to be a weapon at someone. Even the act of pointing a harmless laser pointer can be charged under this statute if it is done in a threatening way.
Penalties:
Violating Penal Code § 417.25 is a misdemeanor, punishable by up to 30 days in jail.
Example:
During a prank, Sarah points a laser pointer at a security guard, pretending to target them. Even though it was a joke, the guard felt threatened, and Sarah could be charged under Penal Code § 417.25 for pointing a laser in a threatening manner.
4. Penal Code § 422 PC – Criminal Threats
Penal Code § 422 PC deals with making criminal threats, which can occur when a person threatens someone else with serious harm or death, even if no weapon is involved. However, if the threat is accompanied by an imitation firearm or real weapon, it can escalate the charge and penalties.
To be convicted of criminal threats, the prosecution must prove that the defendant made a threat that caused the victim to reasonably fear for their safety or the safety of their family.
Penalties:
A violation of Penal Code § 422 can be charged as either a misdemeanor or a felony (a “wobbler” offense).
If convicted of a felony, the defendant could face up to three years in state prison.
Example:
During a confrontation, Alex tells his neighbor that he’s going to kill him while brandishing a fake gun. The neighbor believes the threat is real and fears for his life. Alex could be charged with criminal threats under Penal Code § 422 in addition to Penal Code § 417.4 for brandishing the imitation firearm.
5. Penal Code § 245(a)(1) PC – Assault with a Deadly Weapon
Under Penal Code § 245(a)(1), it is a crime to assault someone with a deadly weapon other than a firearm. This can include knives, clubs, or other objects that are capable of causing serious bodily harm or death. While § 417.4 focuses on imitation firearms, assault with a deadly weapon is much more serious, as it involves an actual attempt to harm someone with a dangerous object.
Penalties:
Assault with a deadly weapon can be charged as a misdemeanor or felony.
As a felony, it carries penalties of up to four years in state prison.
Example:
In a fit of rage, Carlos swings a baseball bat at a coworker but misses. Even though no contact was made, Carlos could be charged with assault with a deadly weapon under Penal Code § 245(a)(1).
6. Penal Code § 25400 PC – Carrying a Concealed Firearm
Penal Code § 25400 makes it illegal to carry a concealed firearm without a permit. If a person is caught with a concealed imitation firearm and brandishes it in a way that causes fear, they could face charges under Penal Code § 417.4 for brandishing the imitation firearm and additional penalties for carrying the concealed weapon if it is a real firearm.
Penalties:
Violating Penal Code § 25400 is usually charged as a misdemeanor, but it can become a felony in cases involving prior convictions, gang involvement, or other aggravating factors.
Penalties can include jail time, fines, and probation.
Example:
Jake carries a concealed BB gun that looks like a real firearm. If he pulls it out and causes fear in another person, he could be charged under both Penal Code § 417.4 for brandishing the imitation gun and Penal Code § 25400 for carrying a concealed weapon.
Protecting Your Rights, Defending Your Future
Get in touch with our lawyers today to schedule a consultation and learn how we can help you. We are here to answer your questions and provide you with the support you need during this difficult time.
Client Satisfaction Is Priority
You Are More Than What They Say
We Always Go The Extra Mile