Penal Code § 591.5 PC - Damaging a Communication Device to Prevent Help
Table of contents
Click To travel To Chapters
1. What is Penal Code § 591.5 PC?
Penal Code § 591.5 PC Law Reads As Followed:
“A person who unlawfully and maliciously removes, injures, destroys, damages, or obstructs the use of any wireless communication device with the intent to prevent the use of the device to summon assistance or notify law enforcement or any public safety agency of a crime is guilty of a misdemeanor.”
2. What Are Examples of Penal Code § 591.5 PC?
California Penal Code § 591.5 PC prohibits the unlawful and malicious destruction, damage, or obstruction of a communication device to prevent someone from seeking help or notifying law enforcement. This law is often associated with cases involving domestic violence, disputes, or heated confrontations, but its application extends to other situations where interference with communication devices occurs.
Below are examples that illustrate violations of Penal Code § 591.5 PC and how the law is enforced:
1. Domestic Disputes
Example 1:
During an argument with his spouse, John grabs her cell phone and smashes it against the wall when she tries to call 911 for help. By doing so, John obstructs her ability to seek assistance from law enforcement.
Example 2:
Sarah and her partner are arguing, and Sarah hides her partner’s cell phone in another room to prevent them from contacting the police. Although she did not destroy the phone, her actions obstructed its use, which falls under Penal Code § 591.5.
2. Altercations Between Acquaintances
Example 3:
At a party, David gets into a physical altercation with another guest. When the guest pulls out their phone to call the police, David snatches it and throws it into the pool. This act of intentionally damaging the phone to stop the person from summoning law enforcement violates Penal Code § 591.5.
Example 4:
Maria is involved in a heated argument with her neighbor. When the neighbor tries to record the dispute on their tablet, Maria grabs it and smashes the screen, preventing them from documenting the event or calling for help.
3. Workplace Incidents
Example 5:
A supervisor confronts an employee about reporting unsafe working conditions. To intimidate the employee, the supervisor takes the employee’s cell phone and damages it to stop them from notifying authorities or HR. This is an example of maliciously obstructing the use of a communication device.
Example 6:
During a workplace argument, an employee destroys a coworker’s phone after learning they were about to call law enforcement to report a theft.
4. Road Rage Incidents
Example 7:
After a road rage altercation, one driver notices the other is attempting to call the police. The enraged driver exits their vehicle, snatches the phone, and throws it onto the pavement, smashing it to pieces.
5. Incidents Involving Strangers
Example 8:
A pickpocket is caught red-handed by a passerby. When the passerby tries to use their phone to call for help, the pickpocket grabs the phone and runs away, later smashing it to avoid being traced. Even though the pickpocket did not steal the phone for personal use, their actions obstructed its use for summoning help.
Example 9:
Debbie gets into a heated confrontation with a stranger who asks to borrow her phone to report a car accident. Instead of lending the phone, Debbie throws it on the ground and breaks it out of frustration. This action can be charged under Penal Code § 591.5.
6. Family Arguments
Example 10:
A teenager, angry with their parent for grounding them, takes the parent’s phone and smashes it to prevent them from calling another family member or seeking outside help.
7. Retaliation Against a Witness
Example 11:
A suspect learns that someone intends to call the police to report a crime they witnessed. In retaliation, the suspect damages the witness’s phone, making it impossible for them to report the crime.
3. What are Common Defenses Against Penal Code § 591.5 PC?
Being charged under Penal Code § 591.5 PC – Damaging a Communication Device to Prevent Help – is a serious matter. However, the law has specific elements that the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt. As such, there are several strong defenses that an experienced criminal defense attorney can use to challenge these charges and potentially have them reduced or dismissed altogether.
Below, we outline the most common defenses against Penal Code § 591.5 PC accusations.
1. Lack of Malicious Intent
To be convicted under Penal Code § 591.5, the prosecution must prove that you acted “maliciously.” Under California law, malicious intent means:
Acting with the intent to harm, annoy, or injure someone, or
Intentionally committing a wrongful act.
Defense Example:
You accidentally dropped someone’s phone during an argument, and it broke. Since you did not intentionally damage the phone with malicious intent, this charge may not hold.
How It Works:
If your attorney can show that your actions were unintentional, careless, or accidental, the malicious intent element required for a conviction is not satisfied.
2. No Intent to Prevent Help
A crucial element of Penal Code § 591.5 is that you must have acted with the specific intent to prevent someone from seeking help or notifying law enforcement. Without this intent, you cannot be found guilty of this offense.
Defense Example:
You damaged someone’s phone in the heat of an argument, but the person was not using the device to call for help or contact authorities. Without the intent to obstruct their ability to seek assistance, this charge may not apply.
How It Works:
Your attorney can argue that while the device may have been damaged, it was not done with the intent to stop the person from summoning help or contacting the police. The prosecution must prove this intent, which can be difficult without direct evidence.
3. False Accusations
False accusations are common in emotionally charged situations, particularly in cases involving domestic violence. Someone may falsely accuse you of damaging their communication device out of anger, jealousy, revenge, or a desire to gain leverage in legal proceedings.
Defense Example:
Your partner accuses you of smashing their phone during an argument, but witnesses or evidence show the phone was already broken before the incident.
How It Works:
An experienced attorney will investigate the circumstances of the accusation, gather evidence, and cross-examine witnesses to reveal inconsistencies or motives behind the false claims.
4. Insufficient Evidence
The burden of proof lies with the prosecution. If there is insufficient evidence to establish that you committed the alleged act or that you did so with the required intent, the charges may be dismissed.
Defense Example:
There is no clear evidence linking you to the damage of the communication device, such as surveillance footage or eyewitness testimony.
How It Works:
Your attorney can argue that the prosecution has failed to meet its burden of proof, resulting in a dismissal of the case.
5. Ownership of the Device
Penal Code § 591.5 applies to unlawfully damaging someone else’s communication device. If the device is your property, you cannot be charged under this law.
Defense Example:
You break your own phone during an argument, and the other person accuses you of violating Penal Code § 591.5. Since you owned the phone, this law does not apply.
How It Works:
Your attorney will establish that the damaged device was your property, which disqualifies the case under Penal Code § 591.5.
6. Device Was Not in Use for Help
Another critical element of Penal Code § 591.5 is that the device was being used or intended to be used to summon help or notify law enforcement. If this was not the case, the charge may not apply.
Defense Example:
You accidentally damaged a phone that the alleged victim was using to check social media, not to contact authorities or summon help.
How It Works:
Your attorney will argue that the device was not being used in the manner required by Penal Code § 591.5, undermining the prosecution’s case.
7. Mistaken Identity
In some cases, you may be wrongly accused due to mistaken identity. If someone else damaged the communication device and you were falsely blamed, this can serve as a valid defense.
Defense Example:
During a chaotic argument at a party, someone else smashes a phone, but the victim mistakenly accuses you of the act.
our clients say it best
Client Testimonials
4. What are The Penalties for Violating Penal Code § 591.5 PC?
California Penal Code § 591.5 PC makes it a misdemeanor to maliciously damage, destroy, or obstruct a communication device, such as a cell phone, with the intent of preventing someone from seeking help or notifying law enforcement. While this offense is considered less severe than a felony, a conviction can still carry significant penalties and long-term consequences.
Below, we explain the potential penalties for violating Penal Code § 591.5 PC, including imprisonment, fines, and other legal repercussions.
1. Jail Time
A violation of Penal Code § 591.5 PC is punishable by up to one year in county jail.
The exact length of time will depend on the circumstances of the case, such as the severity of the act, whether the device was fully destroyed, and any prior criminal history.
2. Fines
In addition to or instead of jail time, a person convicted under Penal Code § 591.5 PC may face a fine of up to $1,000.
This amount is the maximum penalty for this misdemeanor offense, but the court may impose a lower fine depending on the specifics of the case.
3. Probation
In many cases, judges may grant informal probation (also known as summary probation) in lieu of incarceration.
Probation typically lasts up to three years and may include conditions such as:
Completing community service hours.
Attending anger management or counseling programs.
Abiding by a protective order if the offense occurred during a domestic dispute.
Avoiding any further criminal activity.
Failure to comply with the terms of probation can result in additional penalties, including potential jail time.
4. Restitution to the Victim
A person convicted under Penal Code § 591.5 PC may also be required to pay restitution to the victim.
Restitution covers the cost of repairing or replacing the damaged communication device, such as a cell phone or tablet.
This is in addition to any fines imposed by the court.
5. Criminal Record
A conviction under Penal Code § 591.5 PC will result in a misdemeanor on your criminal record.
This record is visible to potential employers, landlords, and others conducting background checks.
A criminal record may impact your ability to find housing or employment, particularly for jobs that require trust and integrity.
6. Collateral Consequences
In addition to the formal penalties, a conviction under Penal Code § 591.5 PC can lead to other long-term consequences, including:
Impact on Custody or Divorce Proceedings: If the offense occurred during a domestic dispute, it could negatively affect child custody arrangements or divorce settlements.
Immigration Consequences: Non-citizens convicted of a crime may face immigration consequences, such as deportation or difficulty obtaining legal residency or citizenship.
Loss of Rights or Privileges: A criminal conviction can affect certain privileges, such as obtaining specific professional licenses or certifications.
Aggravating Factors That May Impact Penalties
Certain circumstances may lead to harsher penalties or additional charges in connection with a Penal Code § 591.5 PC violation, such as:
Repeat Offenses: If the defendant has a prior criminal record, especially for similar offenses, the court may impose more severe punishment.
Domestic Violence Context: If the offense occurred during an incident involving domestic violence, additional charges (e.g., domestic battery or corporal injury) may be filed.
Significant Damage: The extent of the damage to the device can also influence the penalties. Completely destroying an expensive device may lead to higher fines and stricter sentencing.
Penalties for Related Offenses
Violations of Penal Code § 591.5 PC are often charged alongside or in connection with related offenses, which carry their own penalties, including:
Penal Code § 594 PC – Vandalism:
Misdemeanor: Up to 1 year in county jail and/or a fine of up to $1,000.
Felony (if damage exceeds $400): 1 to 3 years in state prison and/or fines up to $10,000.
Penal Code § 243(e)(1) PC – Domestic Battery:
Up to 1 year in county jail and/or a fine of up to $2,000.
Penal Code § 273.5 PC – Corporal Injury on a Spouse or Cohabitant:
Misdemeanor: Up to 1 year in county jail and/or a fine of up to $6,000.
Felony: 2, 3, or 4 years in state prison and/or a fine of up to $6,000.
How to Avoid or Minimize Penalties
If you are facing charges under Penal Code § 591.5 PC, it’s essential to act quickly to protect your rights and explore your legal options. An experienced criminal defense attorney can help by:
Challenging the prosecution’s evidence and showing that key elements of the crime are not met.
Negotiating with the prosecutor to reduce the charge or penalties.
Pursuing alternative sentencing options, such as probation or community service, to avoid jail time.
5. What Are the Related Offenses To Penal Code § 591.5 PC?
Violations of California Penal Code § 591.5 PC, which prohibits damaging or obstructing a communication device to prevent someone from seeking help, often occur alongside or overlap with other criminal offenses. These related offenses are usually tied to domestic violence, property crimes, or interpersonal disputes.
Below, we explore the most common offenses related to Penal Code § 591.5 PC, their legal definitions, and the potential penalties they carry.
1. Penal Code § 594 PC – Vandalism
Under Penal Code § 594 PC, vandalism involves maliciously damaging, destroying, or defacing someone else’s property. Damaging a communication device, such as smashing a cell phone or tablet, can lead to vandalism charges in addition to a § 591.5 violation.
Key Points:
Wobbler Offense:
If the damage exceeds $400, vandalism is a “wobbler,” meaning it can be charged as either a misdemeanor or a felony.
Damage under $400 is charged as a misdemeanor.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor:
Up to 1 year in county jail
Fines up to $1,000 (or $5,000 for repeat offenses)
Felony:
1 to 3 years in state prison
Fines up to $10,000 (or more for extensive damage)
2. Penal Code § 243(e)(1) PC – Domestic Battery
Domestic battery, defined under Penal Code § 243(e)(1) PC, is the unlawful and willful use of force or violence against an intimate partner, such as a spouse, cohabitant, fiancé, or the parent of your child. A Penal Code § 591.5 PC charge often accompanies domestic battery in cases involving heated disputes or physical altercations.
Key Points:
No physical injury is required to be convicted of domestic battery.
The victim must be in a domestic or intimate relationship with the accused.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor:
Up to 1 year in county jail
Fines up to $2,000
Completion of a batterer’s intervention program
3. Penal Code § 273.5 PC – Corporal Injury on a Spouse or Cohabitant
Corporal injury, under Penal Code § 273.5 PC, involves willfully inflicting physical injury on an intimate partner, resulting in a visible injury, whether minor or severe. If the damage to a communication device under Penal Code § 591.5 PC is part of an incident involving physical violence, the defendant may face additional charges under this section.
Key Points:
The injury does not need to be severe; even minor injuries, such as bruises, can qualify.
This is a wobbler offense, meaning it can be charged as a misdemeanor or felony depending on the severity of the incident and the defendant’s prior record.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor:
Up to 1 year in county jail
Fines up to $6,000
Felony:
2, 3, or 4 years in state prison
Fines up to $6,000
4. Penal Code § 591 PC – Damaging a Phone or Electrical Line
While Penal Code § 591 PC shares similarities with Penal Code § 591.5 PC, it applies more broadly to cases involving malicious damage to any phone, electrical, or utility line. For example, cutting a landline phone cord or tampering with a utility line to disrupt communication services could lead to charges under Penal Code § 591.
Key Points:
Unlike § 591.5, which focuses on wireless devices, § 591 covers both wired and wireless communication tools as well as utility lines.
Penalties:
Wobbler Offense:
Misdemeanor: Up to 1 year in county jail
Felony: 16 months, 2 years, or 3 years in state prison
Fines of up to $10,000
5. Penal Code § 422 PC – Criminal Threats
Under Penal Code § 422 PC, criminal threats occur when someone threatens to harm another person, causing them to reasonably fear for their safety. If someone damages a communication device during a threat to prevent the victim from calling for help, they may face both Penal Code § 591.5 and § 422 charges.
Key Points:
A credible threat made verbally, in writing, or via electronic communication qualifies under this law.
The victim must reasonably fear that the threat will be carried out.
Penalties:
Wobbler Offense:
Misdemeanor: Up to 1 year in county jail
Felony: 16 months, 2 years, or 3 years in state prison
Strike under California’s “Three Strikes” law (for felony convictions)
6. Penal Code § 236 PC – False Imprisonment
False imprisonment, under Penal Code § 236 PC, occurs when someone unlawfully restrains, confines, or detains another person against their will. If someone prevents another person from calling for help by damaging their communication device and physically restricting their ability to leave, false imprisonment charges may apply.
Key Points:
The offense does not require physical restraint; actions that make someone feel they cannot leave can qualify.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor:
Up to 1 year in county jail
Felony (with violence or menace):
16 months, 2 years, or 3 years in state prison
7. Penal Code § 602 PC – Trespassing
In situations where someone enters another person’s property unlawfully and damages a communication device to prevent them from seeking help, they may also face charges for trespassing under Penal Code § 602 PC.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor:
Up to 6 months in county jail
Fines up to $1,000
Protecting Your Rights, Defending Your Future
Get in touch with our lawyers today to schedule a consultation and learn how we can help you. We are here to answer your questions and provide you with the support you need during this difficult time.
Client Satisfaction Is Priority
You Are More Than What They Say
We Always Go The Extra Mile