Penal Code § 837 PC - Citizen’s Arrests
1. What is Penal Code § 837 PC?
Penal Code § 837 PC Law Reads As Followed:
A private person may arrest another individual under specific circumstances. These include when a public offense is committed or attempted in their presence, when the individual has committed a felony even if it was not in the private person’s presence, or when a felony has been committed and the private person has reasonable cause to believe the individual they are arresting committed the crime. While this law permits citizen’s arrests, it is crucial to exercise caution and involve law enforcement whenever possible to avoid potential legal and safety issues.
2. What Are Examples of Penal Code § 837 PC?
California Penal Code § 837 PC allows private citizens to make an arrest under specific circumstances. A citizen’s arrest can be lawful when someone witnesses a crime being committed, has reasonable cause to believe a felony occurred, or observes someone attempting to commit a crime. While the law provides this authority, it is essential to understand its limits and practical applications. Below, we explore examples of situations where Penal Code § 837 PC applies, along with important considerations for executing a lawful citizen’s arrest.
Legal Examples of Citizen’s Arrest
Assault in a Public Setting
Imagine Mark is at a bar and witnesses a man throwing a beer bottle at another patron. The bottle misses, but the intent to harm is clear. Mark grabs the man, informs him he is under arrest for attempted assault (Penal Code § 240 PC), and calls the police. Since the offense occurred in Mark’s presence, this is a lawful example of a citizen’s arrest.Theft in a Retail Store
While shopping at a department store, Riley observes another shopper concealing a blouse in her purse. Riley stops the individual, informs her she is under arrest for shoplifting (Penal Code § 459.5 PC), and contacts store security or the police. Because Riley personally witnessed the theft, the arrest complies with Penal Code § 837.Prostitution Solicitation
Lou is walking down the street and sees someone openly soliciting prostitution. Lou stops the individual, informs her she is under arrest for solicitation (Penal Code § 647(b) PC), and calls the authorities. Since the offense occurred in Lou’s presence, this is another valid application of the citizen’s arrest law.Pursuing a Known Felony Offender
Suppose Sarah sees a news report identifying a suspect wanted for robbery. Later, she spots the suspect at a public park. Believing the person to be the offender, Sarah informs the individual she is making a citizen’s arrest and calls the police. Since a felony was committed and Sarah has reasonable cause to believe the person is the culprit, this action may be lawful under Penal Code § 837.
Key Considerations for Citizen’s Arrests
While Penal Code § 837 provides the authority for private citizens to arrest, several factors must be taken into account to avoid legal complications:
Reasonable Cause: You must have a clear and reasonable belief that a crime occurred, and that the individual committed it. Acting on speculation or insufficient evidence could lead to accusations of false arrest.
Prompt Action: A citizen’s arrest should be made immediately following the offense. Delayed actions can complicate the legality of the arrest.
Use of Force: Only reasonable force is allowed to detain the suspect. Excessive or unwarranted force may result in civil or criminal liability.
Informing the Suspect: You must notify the suspect of the reason for the arrest and, if possible, indicate your authority to make the arrest.
Involving Law Enforcement: It is crucial to contact the police immediately after making an arrest to transfer custody of the suspect to authorities.
Risks of Misusing Penal Code § 837
If a citizen’s arrest is made improperly, it can result in serious consequences, including:
False Arrest Claims: If the individual arrested did not commit a crime or there was no reasonable cause for the arrest, the arrestee could file a civil lawsuit seeking damages.
Criminal Charges: Misusing the authority to make a citizen’s arrest can lead to charges of assault, false imprisonment, or kidnapping, depending on the circumstances.
Physical Danger: Attempting to detain a suspect can lead to confrontations that jeopardize the safety of the person making the arrest and others nearby.
3. What are Common Defenses Against Penal Code § 837 PC?
Penal Code § 837 PC gives private citizens the authority to make arrests under specific circumstances, but these arrests are not immune to legal scrutiny. If someone has been arrested by a private citizen, and that arrest is challenged as improper or unlawful, there are several legal defenses that may apply. Understanding these defenses is crucial for protecting your rights and ensuring you are not wrongfully detained. Below, we discuss the common defenses against Penal Code § 837 PC and their application in legal proceedings.
1. Lack of Reasonable Cause
A key requirement for a lawful citizen’s arrest under Penal Code § 837 is that the person making the arrest must have reasonable cause to believe a crime has been committed. If the arresting citizen acted on assumptions, misinformation, or without clear evidence, the arrest may be deemed unlawful. For example, if someone detains a person simply because they match a vague description or were in the vicinity of a crime, the defense can argue that there was no reasonable cause for the arrest.
One of the most straightforward defenses is proving that the defendant did not commit a crime. If the detained individual can show that they were not involved in any illegal activity, the citizen’s arrest lacks legal foundation. For instance, if someone is accused of shoplifting but has a receipt proving they purchased the item, the arrest would be invalid.
Penal Code § 837 allows citizens to use only reasonable force when making an arrest. If the arresting individual uses excessive or unnecessary force, the arrest can be challenged. For example, if someone physically assaults or restrains a person in a harmful or violent way without justification, this can lead to civil liability or even criminal charges for the arresting party. Demonstrating that the use of force was excessive can invalidate the arrest.
4. Improper Arrest Procedure
Certain procedural requirements must be followed for a citizen’s arrest to be lawful. For example, the person making the arrest must:
Inform the individual that they are being arrested.
Clearly state the reason for the arrest.
Notify law enforcement and transfer custody promptly.
If the arresting citizen fails to meet these procedural requirements, the defense can argue that the arrest was improperly conducted and, therefore, invalid.
5. Mistaken Identity
Another common defense is that the citizen arrested the wrong person. Mistaken identity can occur when a citizen acts quickly or impulsively without verifying the suspect’s involvement in a crime. If the defendant can provide an alibi or evidence proving they were not the perpetrator, this defense can lead to dismissal of charges or a lawsuit against the citizen who made the arrest.
6. Unlawful Detention or False Imprisonment
A citizen’s arrest that exceeds the legal scope of Penal Code § 837 can be considered unlawful detention or false imprisonment. If the arresting citizen held the individual for an unreasonable length of time, confined them in a dangerous or degrading manner, or failed to involve law enforcement, the detained individual can claim their rights were violated.
7. Violation of Constitutional Rights
A citizen’s arrest may also be challenged if the arrestee’s constitutional rights were violated. For example, if the arresting individual discriminated against someone based on race, gender, or another protected characteristic, this could render the arrest unlawful. Additionally, any evidence obtained through coercion or intimidation during the arrest could be inadmissible in court.
8. Citizen’s Misinterpretation of the Law
A citizen arresting someone must correctly understand the nature of the alleged crime. If the arresting individual incorrectly interprets the law or mistakenly believes an innocent act is illegal, the arrest can be invalidated. For example, detaining someone for an act that is not criminal (such as accidentally bumping into another person in a store) would be unlawful.
Legal Consequences of an Improper Citizen’s Arrest
When a citizen’s arrest under Penal Code § 837 is determined to be unlawful, the person making the arrest may face legal repercussions, including:
Civil Lawsuits: The detained individual may sue for damages such as lost wages, medical expenses, pain and suffering, and punitive damages.
Criminal Charges: Charges such as assault, battery, false imprisonment, or kidnapping can be filed against the arresting citizen if they acted improperly.
Reputational Harm: The individual making the unlawful arrest may suffer reputational damage, particularly if the incident is widely publicized.
our clients say it best
Client Testimonials
4. What are The Penalties for Violating Penal Code § 837 PC?
Violating the rules set forth in Penal Code § 837 PC can lead to several significant legal consequences, including criminal charges, civil liability, and potential personal injury claims. The penalties depend largely on the circumstances surrounding the violation.
1. False Arrest Charges
If a citizen attempts to make an arrest under Penal Code § 837 without meeting the criteria (e.g., arresting someone for a misdemeanor that wasn’t committed in their presence or for an unlawful felony), they may be subject to false arrest claims. False arrest is a civil offense but can also lead to criminal charges in some cases. The penalties for a false arrest can include:
Civil Penalties: The person who was falsely arrested may file a lawsuit for false imprisonment, which can lead to compensation for emotional distress, lost wages, and legal fees. Additionally, the person who made the false arrest may be liable for punitive damages if the conduct was deemed malicious or egregious.
Criminal Charges: A false arrest, depending on the specific circumstances, could lead to criminal charges of false imprisonment under Penal Code § 236. If convicted, the penalties can include imprisonment for up to one year in county jail and/or fines of up to $1,000. The severity of the penalty often depends on the intent and the manner in which the arrest was carried out.
2. Use of Excessive Force
Penal Code § 837 allows for an arrest, but it must be done without the use of excessive force. If a citizen uses unnecessary violence while attempting an arrest, they may face assault charges, including:
Battery: If the arrest is accompanied by physical violence, the individual may face battery charges under Penal Code § 242. A conviction could lead to up to six months in county jail and/or fines of up to $2,000.
Assault Charges: If the force used is severe, such as causing serious injury, the individual may be charged with assault under Penal Code § 240, which can result in higher penalties, including imprisonment for up to one year and/or fines up to $1,000.
3. Wrongful Detention or Unlawful Imprisonment
When a citizen detains someone without proper justification or legal grounds, they could face wrongful detention or unlawful imprisonment charges. This occurs when an individual is detained against their will without reasonable cause. The penalties can include:
Criminal Liability: A conviction for unlawful imprisonment under Penal Code § 236 can lead to imprisonment for up to one year in county jail and/or a fine of up to $1,000.
Civil Liability: Victims of unlawful imprisonment may also pursue civil lawsuits, which could lead to compensation for damages, including pain and suffering.
4. Interfering with Law Enforcement
A citizen’s arrest is only valid when it complies with the law. If a citizen interferes with law enforcement or disrupts the process of a police investigation, they may face charges of obstructing justice. Under Penal Code § 148, interfering with a peace officer’s duties is a misdemeanor, punishable by:
Up to 1 Year in Jail: If convicted, a person may face up to one year in county jail.
Fines: A fine of up to $1,000 may be imposed as part of the sentence.
5. What Are the Related Offenses To Penal Code § 837 PC?
Penal Code § 837 PC grants private citizens in California the right to make certain types of arrests under specific circumstances. While the statute is clear about what is allowed, there are several offenses related to violating the terms of § 837, as well as other crimes that may arise during or after a citizen’s arrest. Understanding these related offenses is crucial for anyone considering making a citizen’s arrest or for individuals who might be involved in such situations. Below, we explore several related offenses to Penal Code § 837 and the potential consequences for violating California law in these contexts.
1. False Arrest (Penal Code § 236)
One of the most common related offenses to a violation of Penal Code § 837 PC is false arrest. When a citizen attempts to make an arrest without proper legal grounds, such as arresting someone for a crime that was not committed in their presence or for an unlawful felony, they may be committing the offense of false arrest.
Penalties:
Civil Liabilities: The individual who is falsely arrested may pursue a lawsuit for false imprisonment. This can result in damages for emotional distress, loss of income, and punitive damages if the arrest was malicious or unjustified.
Criminal Consequences: If the arresting individual used force or acted recklessly, they may face criminal charges of false imprisonment, with penalties including up to 1 year in county jail and fines up to $1,000.
Key Points to Avoid:
Making an arrest without a valid reason, such as when a misdemeanor is not committed in the arresting individual’s presence, can result in false arrest charges.
Excessive force during an arrest can escalate the situation into an unlawful detention.
When a private citizen uses force while making an arrest, they must ensure the force is reasonable and necessary. Battery can occur if the individual uses excessive force, causing harm to the person being arrested. Even a minor injury during an arrest can lead to battery charges.
Penalties:
Up to 6 months in county jail and/or fines up to $2,000.
If the victim sustains serious injuries or if the battery was particularly egregious, the penalties could be more severe, possibly resulting in felony charges under Penal Code § 243.
Key Points to Avoid:
Excessive force or any level of harm during a citizen’s arrest can lead to charges of battery, even if the original arrest itself was legally justified.
Assault occurs when a person acts with the intent to harm another, causing them to fear imminent physical injury. While battery involves actual physical contact, assault can occur without direct contact. If a citizen attempts an arrest in an aggressive or threatening manner, they could face assault charges.
Penalties:
Assault is typically a misdemeanor punishable by up to 1 year in county jail and/or a fine up to $1,000.
If a weapon is used or the assault results in significant fear or injury, the charge could escalate to a felony with more severe penalties.
Key Points to Avoid:
Threatening someone or attempting to make an arrest in a manner that causes fear of harm could lead to assault charges.
4. Unlawful Detention or Unlawful Imprisonment (Penal Code § 236)
If a private citizen detains someone for a longer period than is legally justified, they could face unlawful detention or unlawful imprisonment charges. Even if an individual has the right to make an arrest under Penal Code § 837, they must not detain the person longer than necessary or beyond what is reasonable.
Penalties:
Up to 1 year in county jail and/or a fine up to $1,000.
Civil Liability: The detained person may pursue a civil claim for damages arising from the unlawful detention.
Key Points to Avoid:
Detaining someone without proper legal authority or for a prolonged period can lead to serious legal consequences.
Reasonable detention must be limited to the time required for law enforcement to arrive and take control of the situation.
5. Obstructing Justice or Resisting Arrest (Penal Code § 148)
While Penal Code § 837 allows a citizen’s arrest, it’s important to understand the relationship between obstructing justice and resisting arrest. If a citizen attempts to arrest someone but obstructs or interferes with law enforcement officers during their investigation or the person’s arrest, they may face charges under Penal Code § 148.
Penalties:
Misdemeanor: The penalties for obstructing justice or resisting arrest may include up to 1 year in county jail and/or fines up to $1,000.
Key Points to Avoid:
Resisting arrest by law enforcement during or after a citizen’s arrest can lead to serious legal consequences.
Interfering with law enforcement while they are carrying out their duties can also lead to criminal charges under this statute.
6. Kidnapping (Penal Code § 207)
While this offense is rare in the context of a citizen’s arrest, kidnapping may apply if a person unlawfully transports or confines someone against their will after a citizen’s arrest. This could occur if the arresting individual moves the person to a different location without legal authority.
Penalties:
Kidnapping is a serious felony with severe penalties, including life imprisonment if the victim is harmed or taken for a ransom or if the individual is moved for an extended period.
Key Points to Avoid:
Moving someone against their will for any extended period, even if you initially believed you were making a lawful arrest, could result in kidnapping charges.
7. Abuse of Power (Civil Lawsuits)
In addition to criminal penalties, private citizens who make unlawful arrests or act outside the scope of Penal Code § 837 may face civil lawsuits for abuse of power. This can lead to substantial financial penalties, including compensation for damages, emotional distress, and punitive damages.
Penalties:
Victims may sue for pain and suffering, mental anguish, and punitive damages.
Key Points to Avoid:
A citizen’s arrest made without proper legal justification or with excessive force can expose the individual to civil suits for damages.
Protecting Your Rights, Defending Your Future
Get in touch with our lawyers today to schedule a consultation and learn how we can help you. We are here to answer your questions and provide you with the support you need during this difficult time.
Client Satisfaction Is Priority
You Are More Than What They Say
We Always Go The Extra Mile