If you have been charged with making criminal threats in California, the prosecution has to prove far more than that someone was upset by something you said. Penal Code 422 requires five separate elements, and a skilled defense attacks the weakest one: your intent, the wording and context of the statement, or whether the other person’s fear was both sustained and reasonable. This guide explains what the law requires, what a conviction can cost, and how a defense is built around your side of the story.
TL;DR
- A criminal threat under PC 422 is a willful threat of death or great bodily injury that is unequivocal, unconditional, immediate and specific, and that causes sustained, reasonable fear.
- Prosecutors must prove all five elements. If one fails, the charge should fail.
- Texts, emails, social media messages and voicemails count. Gestures alone do not.
- A conviction can mean up to one year in county jail or time in state prison.
- What you do in the first days matters: do not contact the accuser, do not explain yourself to police, and speak to a defense attorney early.
Table of Contents
- What California Penal Code 422 actually says
- The five elements the prosecution must prove
- Texts, social media and gestures
- Penalties and consequences of a PC 422 conviction
- Common defenses to a criminal threats charge
- What evidence matters most
- Our perspective: your story is part of the defense
- How Grace Legal Group can help
- What to do if you have been accused or charged
- FAQ
- Sources
What California Penal Code 422 actually says
Under Penal Code 422, it is a crime to willfully threaten to commit a crime that will result in death or great bodily injury to another person. You do not have to intend to carry the threat out. What the law requires is that you intended the statement to be taken as a threat.
The threat must also be so unequivocal, unconditional, immediate and specific that it conveys a gravity of purpose and an immediate prospect of execution. And it must cause the person to reasonably sustain fear for their own safety or the safety of their immediate family. The statute was amended by Stats. 2025, Ch. 554, effective January 1, 2026, and the current text is on the Legislature’s site.
That is a high bar. Plenty of angry, crude or thoughtless remarks never meet it. We explain the statute in more detail on our page about Penal Code 422 criminal threats.
It is a crime of words
The UC Santa Barbara Police Department describes the difference from stalking this way: criminal threats are a “crime of words” rather than a course of conduct. One statement can be enough. That is why these cases can arise from a single argument, a heated phone call or a late-night text, and why the details of exactly what was said matter so much.
The five elements the prosecution must prove
In People v. Toledo, the California Supreme Court broke the offense into five elements, and the prosecution must establish every one of them.
| Element | What it means | Where a defense often pushes |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Willful threat | You threatened a crime resulting in death or great bodily injury | Did you actually say it? Was it a threat of that kind of harm? |
| 2. Specific intent | You meant the statement to be taken as a threat | Venting, joking or hyperbole is not a threat |
| 3. Unequivocal, unconditional, immediate, specific | The words conveyed gravity of purpose and an immediate prospect of carrying them out | Vague, conditional or offhand language |
| 4. Sustained fear | The threat actually caused lasting fear | Was the fear momentary or fleeting? |
| 5. Reasonable fear | A reasonable person in that position would be afraid | History, context, and what the accuser did afterward |
Because the prosecution carries the burden on every row, a defense does not need to disprove the whole case. It needs to show that one element cannot be established beyond a reasonable doubt.
What “great bodily injury” means
The jury instruction on criminal threats, CALCRIM No. 1300, defines great bodily injury as significant or substantial physical injury, greater than minor or moderate harm. A statement about slapping someone, or a vague warning that someone will “regret it,” may not describe that level of harm at all.
What “sustained fear” means
Sustained fear is fear that lasts longer than a momentary, fleeting or transitory reaction. According to the UC Santa Barbara Police Department, even 15 minutes may be enough. So prosecutors do not need weeks of terror, and a defense cannot rely on this element alone. It does, however, make the accuser’s own behavior after the statement relevant: did they stay, reply calmly, keep seeing you, or wait days before reporting?
Texts, social media and gestures
Many of these cases begin on a phone. The statute covers threats made verbally, in writing, or by an electronic communication device, including telephones, cellular telephones, computers, video recorders, fax machines and pagers. A text, a direct message, a voicemail or a post can all be charged.
Nonverbal conduct is different. In People v. Gonzalez (2017), the California Supreme Court held that gestures alone fall outside section 422, because the statute requires a threat made verbally, in writing or by electronic device. Conduct can still be charged under other laws, and it can still be used as context for what words meant, so this is a limit on one charge rather than a guarantee of safety.
If your case grew out of repeated contact, the prosecution may also consider other charges. Our page on defending stalking charges in California covers how those cases differ. If the accusation was a demand for money tied to a threatening letter, that falls under a separate statute, which we describe in our page on extortion by threatening letter.

Penalties and consequences of a PC 422 conviction
A conviction under section 422 can result in imprisonment in county jail for up to one year, or imprisonment in state prison. Which of those applies depends on how the case is charged and resolved, and that is one reason early involvement of a defense attorney matters. A charge that begins as a felony can sometimes be negotiated down, but only if the facts and your background are put in front of the prosecutor in a persuasive way.
The Legislature also treats certain victims as an aggravating factor. For a felony violation of 422(a), a court may consider a willful threat against someone the defendant knew was a state constitutional officer, a Member of the Legislature, a judge or a court commissioner.
New location-based threat law
A newer statute, Penal Code 422.3, was added by Stats. 2025, Ch. 594 and took effect January 1, 2026. It sets criminal penalties for specific threats to commit crimes of death or great bodily injury at places such as schools, workplaces or houses of worship. The penalty is county jail not exceeding one year, or imprisonment under Penal Code 1170(h). If your statement involved a school or workplace, ask your attorney whether this law is in play.
Beyond the sentence itself, any criminal record can affect work, housing, professional licenses and family court. A threat accusation arising from a relationship dispute may also sit alongside a domestic violence allegation. Our domestic violence defense page explains how those cases are handled.
Common defenses to a criminal threats charge
No single defense fits every case. The strongest approach starts by comparing the evidence with each element.
The words were not a true threat
Courts look at whether the words were truly meant to threaten or were hyperbole. According to the UC Santa Barbara Police Department, the context and surrounding circumstances are vital. Frustrated exaggeration, dark humor between friends, or a statement made in the middle of a mutual argument can look very different from a calculated message once the full conversation is read.
The same source cautions that even conditional statements can be treated as true threats when circumstances lead a reasonable person to take them seriously. That is why a defense reads the entire thread or recording, not just the one line the accuser screenshotted.
No specific intent
The prosecution must show you meant the statement to be taken as a threat. Intent is rarely proven by a confession. It is inferred from tone, history, wording and what happened next. A defense can offer a different, believable explanation: you were venting to a third person, you were quoting someone, you were reacting to being provoked.
The threat was not unequivocal, unconditional, immediate or specific
This element is where many cases are won or reduced. A statement such as “you’d better watch yourself” is not the same as a specific, immediate statement of intent to kill or seriously injure. The more vague, conditional or removed in time the words were, the harder it is to show a gravity of purpose.
The fear was not sustained or not reasonable
The accuser’s reaction is central. Did they call police right away or weeks later? Did they keep texting you, invite you over, or continue the relationship? Did they have a reason to exaggerate, such as a custody dispute, a breakup or a workplace conflict? A reasonable person’s fear is judged objectively, so a defense looks at what an ordinary person would have felt in that exact situation.
Self-defense or provocation
Sometimes the statement was made while you were being confronted or were afraid yourself. That does not erase the elements, but it changes how intent and reasonableness look. Our overview of self-defense laws in California explains the principles, and our guide to what defenses are available in most criminal cases covers the broader toolkit.
Constitutional protections for speech
Because section 422 criminalizes speech, the First Amendment is never far away. In People v. Mirmirani, the California Supreme Court applied strict First Amendment standards to a vagueness challenge involving earlier versions of sections 422 and 422.5. The current statute’s tight wording, with its demands for unequivocal and specific words, reflects that concern. A defense attorney can argue that speech which does not meet those requirements is protected.
Attempted criminal threat
Sometimes prosecutors charge an attempt. In People v. Chandler (2014), the California Supreme Court held that an attempted criminal threat requires both subjective intent to threaten and proof that the intended threat would have caused a reasonable person sustained fear. That still leaves the prosecution with real work to do.
What evidence matters most
These cases tend to turn on a small amount of evidence, so details decide outcomes. A defense team usually looks at:
- The full message history. Not a single screenshot, but everything before and after it, including the accuser’s replies.
- Audio, voicemail and video. Tone can change the meaning of a sentence.
- Witnesses. Anyone who heard the exchange or saw how the accuser acted afterward.
- Timing of the report. A delay can bear on whether the fear was sustained and reasonable.
- Motive. Disputes over custody, money, property or a breakup can color an accusation.
- Your background. Employment, family, community ties and the absence of any history of violence.
The last item is more than character. It becomes part of the story a mitigation packet tells.
Our perspective: your story is part of the defense
We see criminal threats charges differently from many firms, because most of the people who come to us are not dangerous. They said something in the worst moment of a bad week, and a sentence out of context has become a felony allegation. A prosecutor reading a police report sees a name, a quote and a complaint. They do not see the person.
That is why we build a detailed mitigation packet for each client. It documents who you are, your work, your family, your history and the circumstances around the statement, with the aim of changing how the prosecutor perceives the case. Our team includes former law enforcement professionals, who know how reports are written and where they leave gaps, and every client has two dedicated attorneys working the file. We work from a faith-based approach that treats every client as more than a charge, and we believe early action can help reduce or even eliminate charges.
There are things we ask every client to do from day one: stop contacting the accuser, stay off social media about the case, keep every message and record exactly as it is, and do not give police your version of events without counsel. Those steps cost nothing and protect a great deal.
— Jake
How Grace Legal Group can help
If you are facing a PC 422 allegation, we can review the police report and the messages, identify which element the prosecution will struggle to prove, and prepare your mitigation packet before key decisions are made. Two attorneys work on your case, supported by former law enforcement professionals who help analyze the evidence. Learn more about our criminal defense practice or contact us to talk about your situation.

If the allegation involves force as well as words, our guide to how defense attorneys fight assault, battery and homicide allegations explains how related violent crime cases are handled. Where the statement was made in a public setting and the charge is lesser, see our page on disturbing the peace.
What to do if you have been accused or charged
- Stop all contact with the accuser. Do not apologize, explain or ask them to drop it. Messages like these are often used as evidence, and if a protective order exists, contact can create a new charge.
- Do not delete anything. Deleting messages can look like hiding something. Preserve your phone, accounts and any recordings as they are.
- Do not talk to police without a lawyer. Anything you say, even to explain yourself, can fill gaps in the prosecution’s case on intent.
- Write down your own account. Do it for your attorney only: what was said, when, where, who was present and what led up to it.
- List witnesses and supporting records. Include people who know you, your employer, and anyone who saw the exchange.
- Call a criminal defense attorney early. The earlier a lawyer can speak to the prosecutor, the more room there is to shape how the case is charged.
The statute and its penalties can change, as the 2026 amendments show. Always confirm the current text of Penal Code 422 with your attorney.
FAQ
Can I be charged with criminal threats for a single text message?
Yes. Section 422 covers threats made in writing or by electronic communication device, and one statement can be enough. Whether it holds up depends on whether that message meets all five elements, including specific intent and reasonable, sustained fear.
Do I have to intend to carry out the threat to be convicted?
No. The statute applies even without an intent to carry the threat out, as long as you intended the statement to be taken as a threat. That is why the context of your words and your intent are the focus of most defenses.
Is making a threatening gesture a criminal threat?
Not under section 422 by itself. The California Supreme Court held in People v. Gonzalez that gestures alone fall outside the statute. Other charges may still apply, and gestures can be used as context for spoken or written words.
What is the penalty for criminal threats in California?
A conviction can lead to up to one year in county jail or imprisonment in state prison. The result depends on how the case is charged and resolved, which is why early defense work matters.
Can a criminal threats charge be dismissed or reduced?
It can be, when the evidence fails on one of the five elements or when mitigating facts persuade the prosecutor to change the charge. We cannot promise an outcome in any case, but a prepared defense gives you the best chance at one.
Sources
- California Penal Code section 422
- California Penal Code, Title 11.5 (sections 422 aggravating factors and 422.3)
- People v. Toledo (2001)
- People v. Gonzalez (2017)
- People v. Chandler (2014)
- People v. Mirmirani (1981)
- CALCRIM No. 1300, Criminal Threat
- UC Santa Barbara Police Department: Stalking and Criminal Threats